So S K, Gillingham K, Cook M, Mauer S M, Matas A, Nevins T E, Chavers B M, Najarian J S
Department of Surgery, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, Missouri 63110.
Transplantation. 1990 Dec;50(6):979-83. doi: 10.1097/00007890-199012000-00016.
The role of cadaver kidney transplantation in the management of end-stage renal disease in young children is controversial. To assess the current risk-benefit ratio of cadaver first and second kidney transplants in recipients under 6 years of age, we compared the outcome of 19 transplants performed between 1984 and 1989 using a quadruple-drug regimen (Minnesota antilymphocyte globulin, azathioprine, prednisone, cyclosporine) with the outcome of 25 transplants performed prior to 1984 without the use of cyclosporine at a single institution. Twenty-five transplants were in children under the age of 3 years. In the last decade patient survival has significantly improved. One-year patient survival improved from 53% before 1979 to 90% since 1979 (P less than 0.05). The use of the quadruple-drug regimen since 1984 was associated with a significant improvement in one-year cadaver graft function from 40% before 1979 to 78% in recipients under 6 years of age, and from 22% to 82% in recipients under 3 years of age (P less than 0.05). With the quadruple-drug regimen, one-year and four-year graft function rates for children under 6 years of age were 83% for first cadaver transplants and 72% for second cadaver transplants, which were essentially the same results as in older children and adults. Children who received kidneys from donors over 4 years of age achieved the best result, with 87% one-year graft function compared with 50% for kidneys from donors under 4 years old. In 15 children with successful transplants, 8 (53%) showed accelerated growth, 5 (33%) had normal-velocity growth, and only 2 children (14%) with suboptimal renal function had poor growth following transplantation. Therefore, we believe that with a quadruple-drug immunosuppressive protocol, cadaver renal transplantation using kidneys from adults or pediatric donors over 4 years old is an acceptable form of treatment in young children with end-stage renal disease for whom there are no suitable living-related donors.
尸体肾移植在幼儿终末期肾病治疗中的作用存在争议。为评估6岁以下受者接受首次和第二次尸体肾移植的当前风险效益比,我们比较了1984年至1989年期间采用四联药物方案(明尼苏达抗淋巴细胞球蛋白、硫唑嘌呤、泼尼松、环孢素)进行的19例移植与1984年之前在单一机构进行的25例未使用环孢素的移植的结果。25例移植受者为3岁以下儿童。在过去十年中,患者生存率有了显著提高。1年患者生存率从1979年以前的53%提高到1979年以后的90%(P<0.05)。自1984年以来使用四联药物方案使6岁以下受者1年尸体肾移植功能从1979年以前的40%显著提高到78%,3岁以下受者从22%提高到82%(P<0.05)。采用四联药物方案时,6岁以下儿童首次尸体肾移植的1年和4年移植肾功能率分别为83%,第二次尸体肾移植为72%,这与较大儿童和成人的结果基本相同。接受4岁以上供者肾脏的儿童取得了最佳结果,1年移植肾功能率为87%,而接受4岁以下供者肾脏的为50%。在15例移植成功的儿童中,8例(53%)生长加速,5例(33%)生长速度正常,只有2例(14%)肾功能欠佳的儿童移植后生长不良。因此,我们认为,对于没有合适的亲属活体供者的幼儿终末期肾病患者,采用四联药物免疫抑制方案,使用成人或4岁以上儿童供者的肾脏进行尸体肾移植是一种可接受的治疗方式。