Rustemeyer Jan, Martin Alice
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Medical Centre Bremen-Mitte, School of Medicine, University of Göttingen, Bremen, Germany.
Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2013 Mar;17(1):33-41. doi: 10.1007/s10006-012-0330-0. Epub 2012 May 5.
Since improvement of facial aesthetics after orthognathic surgery moves increasingly into the focus of patients, prediction of soft tissue response to hard tissue movement becomes essential for planning. The aim of this study was to assess the facial soft tissue response in skeletal class II and III patients undergoing orthognathic surgery and to compare the potentials of cephalometry and two-dimensional (2-D) photogrammetry for predicting soft tissue changes.
Twenty-eight patients with class II relationship and 33 with class III underwent bimaxillary surgery. All subjects had available both a traced lateral cephalogram and a traced lateral photogram taken pre- and postsurgery in natural head position (median follow-up, 9.4 ± 0.6 months).
Facial convexity and lower lip length were highly correlated with hard tissue movements cephalometrically in class III patients and 2-D photogrammetrically in both classes. In comparison, cephalometric correlations for class II patients were weak. Correlations of hard and soft tissue movements between pre- and postoperative corresponding landmarks in horizontal and vertical planes were significant for cephalometry and 2-D photogrammetry. No significant difference was found between cephalometry and 2-D photogrammetry with respect to soft to hard tissue movement ratios.
This study revealed that cephalometry is still a feasible standard for evaluating and predicting outcomes in routine orthognathic surgery cases. Accuracy could be enhanced with 2-D photogrammetry, especially in class II patients.
由于正颌外科手术后面部美学的改善越来越成为患者关注的焦点,预测软组织对硬组织移动的反应对于手术规划至关重要。本研究的目的是评估接受正颌手术的安氏II类和III类患者的面部软组织反应,并比较头影测量法和二维(2-D)摄影测量法预测软组织变化的潜力。
28例安氏II类患者和33例安氏III类患者接受了双颌手术。所有受试者均有术前和术后在自然头位拍摄的描记侧位头影图和描记侧位摄影图(中位随访时间,9.4±0.6个月)。
在安氏III类患者中,面部凸度和下唇长度与头影测量的硬组织移动高度相关,在两类患者中与二维摄影测量也高度相关。相比之下,安氏II类患者的头影测量相关性较弱。头影测量法和二维摄影测量法在水平和垂直平面上术前和术后相应标志点之间的硬组织和软组织移动相关性均显著。在软组织与硬组织移动比例方面,头影测量法和二维摄影测量法之间未发现显著差异。
本研究表明,头影测量法仍是评估和预测常规正颌手术病例结果的可行标准。二维摄影测量法可提高准确性,尤其是在安氏II类患者中。