School of Social and Community Medicine, Canynge Hall, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK.
Palliat Med. 2012 Oct;26(7):954-8. doi: 10.1177/0269216312445296. Epub 2012 May 4.
It is mandatory in many countries for decisions for all new patients with cancer to be made within multi-disciplinary teams (MDTs). Whether patients with disease recurrence should also routinely be discussed by the MDT is unknown.
This study investigated the role of an upper gastro intestinal (UGI) MDT in decision-making for patients with disease recurrence.
A retrospective review of prospectively kept MDT records (2010 to 2011) was performed identifying patients discussed with recurrence of oesophagogastric cancer. Information was recorded about: i) why an MDT referral was made, ii) who made the referral and iii) the final MDT recommendation. Implementation of the MDT recommendation was also examined.
All patients discussed with recurrence of cancer at a central UGI cancer MDT were included.
During the study 54 MDT meetings included discussions regarding 304 new patients and 29 with disease recurrence. Referrals to the MDT for patients with recurrence came from outpatient clinics (n=19, 65.5%) or following emergency admission (n=10). Most referrals were made by the surgical team (n=25, 86.2%). MDT recommendations were best supportive care (n=11, 37.9%), palliative chemotherapy (n=9, 31.0%), stent (n=5, 17.2%), palliative radiotherapy (n=3, 10.3%) and further surgery (n=1, 3.4%), with 25 (86.2%) of these implemented.
UGI MDTs focus on new referrals and only a small proportion of patients with recurrent disease are re-discussed. Many patients go on to receive further treatments. Whether such patients are optimally managed within the standard MDT is uncertain, however, and warrants further consideration.
在许多国家,对所有新发癌症患者的决策都必须在多学科团队(MDT)中做出。对于疾病复发的患者,是否也应常规由 MDT 进行讨论尚不清楚。
本研究调查了上消化道(UGI)MDT 在疾病复发患者决策中的作用。
对前瞻性保留的 MDT 记录(2010 年至 2011 年)进行回顾性审查,确定了讨论过食管胃交界部癌症复发的患者。记录了以下信息:i)MDT 转诊的原因,ii)谁提出了转诊,iii)MDT 的最终建议。还检查了 MDT 建议的实施情况。
所有在中央 UGI 癌症 MDT 讨论过癌症复发的患者均包括在内。
在研究期间,54 次 MDT 会议讨论了 304 名新患者和 29 名疾病复发患者。针对复发患者的 MDT 转诊来自门诊(n=19,65.5%)或紧急入院后(n=10)。大多数转诊由外科团队提出(n=25,86.2%)。MDT 的建议是最佳支持性护理(n=11,37.9%)、姑息性化疗(n=9,31.0%)、支架(n=5,17.2%)、姑息性放疗(n=3,10.3%)和进一步手术(n=1,3.4%),其中 25 例(86.2%)得到实施。
UGI MDT 专注于新的转诊,只有一小部分复发性疾病患者会重新讨论。许多患者继续接受进一步治疗。然而,此类患者在标准 MDT 中是否得到最佳管理尚不确定,值得进一步考虑。