Department of Epidemiology, Radiation Effects Research Foundation, 5-2 Hijiyama Park, Minami-ku, Japan.
Radiat Res. 2012 Jul;178(1):86-98. doi: 10.1667/rr2841.1. Epub 2012 May 25.
Among the Life Span Study (LSS) of Atomic-bomb survivors, recent estimates showed that unspecified bladder cancer had high radiation sensitivity with a notably high female-to-male excess relative risk (ERR) per radiation dose ratio and were the only sites for which the ERR did not decrease with attained age. These findings, however, did not consider lifestyle factors, which could potentially confound or modify the risk estimates. This study estimated the radiation risks of the most prevalent subtype of urinary tract cancer, urothelial carcinoma, while accounting for smoking, consumption of fruit, vegetables, alcohol and level of education (a surrogate for socioeconomic status). Eligible study subjects included 105,402 (males = 42,890) LSS members who were cancer-free in 1958 and had estimated radiation doses. Members were censored due to loss of follow-up, incident cancer of another type, death, or the end of calendar year 2001. Surveys (by mail or clinical interview) gathered lifestyle data periodically for 1963-1991. There were 63,827 participants in one or more survey. Five hundred seventy-three incident urothelial carcinoma cases occurred, of which 364 occurred after lifestyle information was available. Analyses were performed using Poisson regression methods. The excess relative risk per weighted gray unit (the gamma component plus 10 times the neutron component, Gy(w)) was 1.00 (95% CI: 0.43-1.78) but the risks were not dependent upon age at exposure or attained age. Lifestyle factors other than smoking were not associated with urothelial carcinoma risk. Neither the magnitude of the radiation ERR estimate (1.00 compared to 0.96), nor the female-to-male (F:M) ERR/Gy(w) ratio (3.2 compared to 3.4) were greatly changed after accounting for all lifestyle factors. A multiplicative model of gender-specific radiation and smoking effects was the most revealing though there was no evidence of significant departures from either the additive or multiplicative joint effect models. Among the LSS cohort members with doses greater than 0.005 Gy(w) (average dose 0.21 Gy(w)), the attributable fraction of urothelial carcinoma due to radiation was 7.1% in males and 19.7% in females. Among current smokers, the attributable fraction of urothelial carcinoma due to smoking was 61% in males and 52% in females. Relative risk estimates of smoking risk were approximately two for smokers compared to nonsmokers. After adjustment for lifestyle factors, gender-specific radiation risks and the F:M ERR/Gy(w), the ratios of excess urothelial carcinoma risk were similar to the estimates without adjusting for lifestyle factors. Smoking was the primary factor responsible for excess urothelial carcinoma in this cohort. These findings led us to conclude that the radiation risk estimates of urothelial carcinoma do not appear to be strongly confounded or modified by smoking, consumption of alcohol, fruits, or vegetables, or level of education.
在原子爆炸幸存者的生命跨度研究(LSS)中,最近的估计表明,未指定的膀胱癌对辐射具有高度敏感性,每辐射剂量比的女性与男性超额相对风险(ERR)明显较高,并且是唯一的部位,ERR 随实际年龄的增加而降低。然而,这些发现并未考虑生活方式因素,这些因素可能会使风险估计产生混杂或改变。本研究在考虑吸烟、水果、蔬菜、酒精和教育水平(社会经济地位的替代指标)等生活方式因素的情况下,估计了最常见的尿路膀胱癌(尿路上皮癌)的辐射风险。符合条件的研究对象包括 105402 名(男性=42890 名)LSS 成员,他们在 1958 年无癌症且接受了估计的辐射剂量。成员因失访、另一种类型的癌症发作、死亡或 2001 年日历年结束而被剔除。调查(通过邮件或临床访谈)定期收集 1963-1991 年的生活方式数据。有 63827 名参与者参加了一次或多次调查。发生了 573 例尿路上皮癌病例,其中 364 例发生在有生活方式信息之后。使用泊松回归方法进行分析。每加权灰区单位(伽马成分加 10 倍中子成分,Gy(w))的超额相对风险为 1.00(95%CI:0.43-1.78),但风险与暴露时的年龄或实际年龄无关。除吸烟以外的生活方式因素与膀胱癌风险无关。辐射 ERR 估计值的幅度(1.00 与 0.96 相比)以及女性与男性(F:M)ERR/Gy(w)比值(3.2 与 3.4 相比)在考虑所有生活方式因素后并未发生很大变化。虽然没有证据表明附加或乘法联合效应模型存在显著偏离,但性别特异性辐射和吸烟效应的乘法模型最具揭示性。在剂量大于 0.005 Gy(w)(平均剂量 0.21 Gy(w))的 LSS 队列成员中,男性归因于辐射的膀胱癌比例为 7.1%,女性为 19.7%。在当前吸烟者中,男性归因于吸烟的膀胱癌比例为 61%,女性为 52%。与不吸烟者相比,吸烟者的膀胱癌相对风险估计值约为两倍。在调整生活方式因素、性别特异性辐射风险和 F:M ERR/Gy(w)后,与未调整生活方式因素相比,过度膀胱癌风险的比值相似。吸烟是该队列中膀胱癌过量的主要原因。这些发现使我们得出结论,膀胱癌的辐射风险估计值似乎没有受到吸烟、酒精、水果或蔬菜消费或教育水平的强烈混杂或改变。