Warlé-Van Herwaarden Margaretha F, Roukens Monique, Pop Gheorghe A M, Lamfers Evert J P, De Smet Peter A G M, Kramers Cornelis
IQ Healthcare, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Eur J Prev Cardiol. 2014 Feb;21(2):231-43. doi: 10.1177/2047487312451253. Epub 2012 Jun 8.
To prevent cardiovascular complications, sometimes double and triple therapy with a vitamin K antagonist (VKA), clopidogrel and/or acetylsalicylic acid (ASA) are indicated. These combinations increase the patient's risk of serious bleeding events. Therefore, adherence to clinical guidelines is of the utmost importance when these high-risk therapies are prescribed.
We performed a retrospective cohort study of 238 cases in a community pharmacy that were treated with a combination of VKA, clopidogrel and/or ASA between January 2006 and December 2009. Hospital records and community pharmacy records were used to obtain the indication(s), the duration of combination therapy, the presence of risk-increasing and risk-decreasing co-medications and any relevant co-morbidities. The cardiologists' attitudes towards the prescribing of antithrombotic combinations and their self-reported adherence to guidelines were assessed by a brief questionnaire.
We found there was no guideline-based indication for 22 of the 146 cases (14%) on ASA plus clopidogrel and 19 of the 82 cases (23%) on VKA plus ASA. Of the 238 cases given antithrombotic combination therapies, 77 (32%) were placed at an additional increased risk of serious gastrointestinal events, yet 43 (56%) of these did not receive adequate gastric protection. Out of the 19 of 60 cardiologists (32%) who responded to our questionnaire; 17 (90%) and 13 (68%) stated that a strict indication is very important when initiating therapy with ASA plus clopidogrel or ASA plus VKA, respectively.
There is room to further develop adherence to guideline-based prescribing of antithrombotic combination therapies and to improve prescription of gastric protection for patients receiving these high-risk combinations.
为预防心血管并发症,有时会采用维生素K拮抗剂(VKA)、氯吡格雷和/或阿司匹林(ASA)进行双重或三重治疗。这些联合用药会增加患者发生严重出血事件的风险。因此,在开具这些高风险治疗药物时,严格遵循临床指南至关重要。
我们对一家社区药房在2006年1月至2009年12月期间接受VKA、氯吡格雷和/或ASA联合治疗的238例患者进行了回顾性队列研究。利用医院记录和社区药房记录获取用药指征、联合治疗持续时间、增加风险和降低风险的合并用药情况以及任何相关的合并症。通过一份简短问卷评估心脏病专家对抗血栓联合用药处方的态度以及他们自我报告的遵循指南情况。
我们发现,在146例接受ASA加氯吡格雷治疗的患者中,有22例(14%)无基于指南的用药指征;在82例接受VKA加ASA治疗的患者中,有19例(23%)无基于指南的用药指征。在接受抗血栓联合治疗的238例患者中,77例(32%)发生严重胃肠道事件的风险进一步增加,但其中43例(56%)未得到充分的胃保护。在回复我们问卷的60位心脏病专家中,有19位(32%);其中分别有17位(90%)和13位(68%)表示,在开始使用ASA加氯吡格雷或ASA加VKA治疗时,严格的用药指征非常重要。
在进一步提高遵循抗血栓联合治疗指南处方方面仍有空间,同时也需要改善接受这些高风险联合治疗患者的胃保护处方情况。