Department of Neurology, Asan Medical Center, University of Ulsan College of Medicine, 388-1 Pungnap-2-Dong, Songpa-Gu, Seoul 138-736, Republic of Korea.
Neurol Sci. 2013 Jun;34(6):875-81. doi: 10.1007/s10072-012-1139-1. Epub 2012 Jun 28.
Neurodegenerative overlap syndrome has been considered as a wide spectrum of motor neuron disease (MND), parkinsonism, or dementia. Specially, clinically overt parkinsonism occurs more often than expected in patients with motor neuron disease (MND), and diverse clinical manifestations of concurrent parkinsonism have been reported. We aimed to clarify clinical and functional imaging characteristics in patients with combined MND and parkinsonism. Of 732 patients diagnosed with MND over 22 consecutive years, eight patients (all men; mean age 62.8 years) exhibited parkinsonism. According to their parkinsonian features and presence of other neurologic signs including dementia, extraocular movement abnormalities, and cerebellar or autonomic dysfunction, they were classified into two groups: MND-parkinsonism (MND-P, n = 5) and MND-parkinsonism-plus syndrome (MND-Plus, n = 3). In the MND-P group, parkinsonism was asymmetric, dominated by resting tremor, and responsive to levodopa. [(18)F] N-(3-fluoropropyl)-2β-carbon ethoxy-3β-(4-iodophenyl) nortropane (FP-CIT) positron emission tomography (PET) in two patients disclosed asymmetrically reduced uptakes in the dorsolateral putamen. In the MND-Plus group, parkinsonism was symmetric, with akinetic rigidity and postural instability dominance, and unresponsive to levodopa. [(18)F] FP-CIT PET scan in one patient showed decreased uptake in bilateral caudate nuclei and putamina. In conclusion, patients with MND and concurrent parkinsonism have heterogeneous clinical and imaging characteristics, which could be classified as features of PD and parkinsonism-plus syndrome. Patients with MND-P may have nigrostriatal dysfunction, and their parkinsonism may respond to levodopa treatment.
神经退行性重叠综合征被认为是广泛的运动神经元病 (MND)、帕金森病或痴呆症。特别是,在运动神经元病 (MND) 患者中,临床上明显的帕金森病比预期更为常见,并且已经报道了并发帕金森病的多种临床表现。我们旨在阐明合并 MND 和帕金森病患者的临床和功能影像学特征。在连续 22 年诊断的 732 名 MND 患者中,有 8 名患者(均为男性;平均年龄 62.8 岁)表现出帕金森病。根据他们的帕金森病特征以及其他神经系统体征的存在,包括痴呆、眼球运动异常、小脑或自主神经功能障碍,他们被分为两组:MND-帕金森病 (MND-P,n=5) 和 MND-帕金森病-plus 综合征 (MND-Plus,n=3)。在 MND-P 组中,帕金森病呈不对称性,以静止性震颤为主,对左旋多巴有反应。两名患者的 [(18)F] N-(3-氟丙基)-2β-碳乙氧基-3β-(4-碘苯基)降冰片烷(FP-CIT)正电子发射断层扫描 (PET) 显示背外侧纹状体摄取不对称减少。在 MND-Plus 组中,帕金森病呈对称性,以运动不能性僵硬和姿势不稳为主,对左旋多巴无反应。一名患者的 [(18)F] FP-CIT PET 扫描显示双侧尾状核和壳核摄取减少。总之,合并 MND 和帕金森病的患者具有异质性的临床和影像学特征,可分为 PD 和帕金森病-plus 综合征的特征。MND-P 患者可能存在黑质纹状体功能障碍,其帕金森病可能对左旋多巴治疗有反应。