Centre for Mental Health & Risk, University of Manchester, UK.
Behav Sci Law. 2012 Jul-Aug;30(4):406-19. doi: 10.1002/bsl.2017. Epub 2012 Jul 3.
Assessing risk of violence in the short term is crucial for managing and preventing violence, especially in institutions such as psychiatric units and prisons. Despite a lack of consensus on the definition of "short term", a number of recent tools and guidelines have been developed to aid short-term clinical decision-making. Whereas the supporting evidence for the new tools is impressive, limitations remain in terms of the focus on prediction, limited consideration of strengths, and poor integration with formulation and risk management. The Short-Term Assessment of Risk and Treatability (START) is a brief clinical guide for the dynamic assessment of risks, strengths and treatability. It focuses on short-term risks and the characteristics of the individual that, if changed, might lead to an increase or decrease in risk. The START has the potential to operationalize the structured professional judgment (SPJ) approach in order to inform the evaluation of multiple risk domains relevant to everyday psychiatric clinical practice. However, explicit guidance on integrating risk assessment, formulation and management is limited in the START and this paper describes the SPJ approach, reviews recent developments in approaches to risk, and considers how the START can be used to inform SPJ approaches and link risk assessment, formulation, and management.
短期评估暴力风险对于管理和预防暴力至关重要,特别是在精神病院和监狱等机构中。尽管对于“短期”的定义尚未达成共识,但已经开发出了一些新的工具和指南来辅助短期临床决策。虽然新工具的支持证据令人印象深刻,但在预测方面仍然存在局限性,对优势的考虑有限,并且与制定和风险管理的整合不佳。短期风险评估和可治疗性(START)是一种用于动态评估风险、优势和可治疗性的简短临床指南。它侧重于短期风险和个体的特征,如果这些特征发生变化,可能会导致风险增加或减少。START 有可能将结构化专业判断(SPJ)方法付诸实践,以便为日常精神病临床实践中与多个风险领域相关的评估提供信息。然而,在 START 中,关于整合风险评估、制定和管理的明确指导是有限的,本文描述了 SPJ 方法,回顾了风险评估方法的最新进展,并考虑了如何使用 START 为 SPJ 方法提供信息并链接风险评估、制定和管理。