Ismail Samina, Shafiq Faraz, Malik Aliya
Department of Anaesthesia, Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi.
J Pak Med Assoc. 2012 Apr;62(4):363-7.
The percentage use of regional anaesthesia (RA) and failure rate of RA for different grades of caesarean section (CS) has become a marker of quality for obstetric anaesthesia service. The objective of our prospective observational study is to find out the technique of anaesthesia used in different grades of CS, reasons for choosing general anaesthesia (GA) and failure rate of RA in our hospital setting.
This prospective cross sectional study was carried in the obstetric unit of Aga Khan University Hospital from 1st January 2010 to 31st May 2011. The anaesthetist performing the procedure filled out the data collection proforma .Suggested Indicators were percentages of Grade 1-4 CS done under RA and GA, percent of failed regional, percent of failed regional in different grades of CS.
A total of 407 patients having undergone Caesarian Section (CS) were reviewed. General Anaesthesia (GA) was used in 201(49%) patients and Regional Anaesthesia (RA) in 206 (51%) patients. There was no significant difference between the use of GA and RA for grade 2-4 CS {grade 2: GA 42 (51%), RA 40 (49%), grade 3: GA 43 (46%), RA 39 (53%), grade 4: GA 81 (44%), RA 101 (55%) with a slight increase margin of difference for grade 1 CS (GA 44 (63%) vs RA 26 (37%)}. Patient preference 42 (45%)was the most common reason for choosing General Anaesthesia.. Fourteen (6.7%) patients required conversion from regional technique to GA. Of these 11 patients had Grade 1-3 CS and three patients had grade 4 or elective CS.
A large percentage (49%) of patients preferred general anaesthesia for CS which is of the International standards. This calls for guidelines regarding the use of Regional Anaesthesia for different grades Caesarian Section. Patient education regarding the use and benefits of Regional Anaesthesia needs to enforced.
不同等级剖宫产术中区域麻醉(RA)的使用率及RA的失败率已成为产科麻醉服务质量的一个指标。我们这项前瞻性观察研究的目的是找出我院不同等级剖宫产术中所采用的麻醉技术、选择全身麻醉(GA)的原因以及RA的失败率。
这项前瞻性横断面研究于2010年1月1日至2011年5月31日在阿迦汗大学医院产科进行。实施麻醉的麻醉医生填写数据收集表格。建议指标包括在RA和GA下进行1 - 4级剖宫产的百分比、区域麻醉失败的百分比、不同等级剖宫产中区域麻醉失败的百分比。
共对407例行剖宫产术的患者进行了回顾。201例(49%)患者采用全身麻醉(GA),206例(51%)患者采用区域麻醉(RA)。2 - 4级剖宫产中GA和RA的使用情况无显著差异{2级:GA 42例(51%),RA 40例(49%);3级:GA 43例(46%),RA 39例(53%);4级:GA 81例(44%),RA 101例(55%)},1级剖宫产的差异幅度略有增加(GA 44例(63%)对RA 26例(37%))。患者偏好(42例(45%))是选择全身麻醉最常见的原因。14例(6.7%)患者需要从区域麻醉技术转为GA。其中11例患者为1 - 3级剖宫产,3例患者为4级或择期剖宫产。
很大比例(49%)的患者剖宫产时倾向于全身麻醉,这符合国际标准。这就需要制定不同等级剖宫产区域麻醉使用的指南。需要加强对患者关于区域麻醉使用及其益处的教育。