Angthong Chayanin, Kanitnate Supakit
Foot and Ankle Surgery, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Thammasat University, Pathum Thani, Thailand.
J Nippon Med Sch. 2012;79(3):198-203. doi: 10.1272/jnms.79.198.
Several authors have recently reported the benefits of endoscopic gastrocnemius recession (EGR) for the treatment of nontraumatic equinus contracture. However, little is known about its potential for correcting severe posttraumatic equinus contracture. This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of dual-portal EGR in patients with severe, intractable equinus following severe trauma to the leg and foot. The recent technique of EGR with supplemental modified procedures was reviewed to improve its capability for correcting deformities and to provide information to avoid complications.
The subjects were 4 patients with intractable, progressive, severe posttraumatic soft-tissue equinus contractures after at least 3 months of unsuccessful conservative treatment. The exclusion criteria were spastic contracture, including osseous equinus. One patient with gastrocnemius equinus underwent EGR alone as a straightforward correction. Three patients with gastrocnemius-soleus equinus underwent EGR to correct the gastrocnemius component followed by a modified percutaneous tendo-Achilles lengthening (TAL) procedure to correct any residual deformities. All data of the preoperative period and each successive postoperative period (1, 3, and 6-12 months) were prospectively collected and included the degree of ankle dorsiflexion, American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) clinical rating scale score, the Visual Analogue Scale-Foot and Ankle (VAS-FA) score, and any related complications. Intraoperatively, the degree of ankle-dorsiflexion was recorded immediately following each procedure.
The mean increase in intraoperative dorsiflexion was 35° ± 9.1° (range: 25°-45°) in all 4 patients and 21.7° ± 10.4° (range, 10°-30°) in the 3 patients undergoing EGR and modified TAL, respectively. There were significant differences in the improvements (p<0.05) in the preoperative period and each successive postoperative period in the increased values of ankle dorsiflexion, AOFAS scores, and VAS-FA scores. There were no significant iatrogenic complications.
Intractable, severe posttraumatic equinus is not commonly encountered by orthopaedic surgeons. Despite the rarity of this condition, which is responsible for the limited number of patients in this series, our results indicates that dual-portal EGR, with or without modified TAL, is a promising treatment, with satisfactory effectiveness and lower risks of complications, for correcting this problematic deformity.
近期有多位作者报道了内镜下腓肠肌松解术(EGR)治疗非创伤性马蹄足挛缩的益处。然而,对于其纠正严重创伤后马蹄足挛缩的潜力知之甚少。本研究旨在评估双切口EGR治疗严重、难治性腿部和足部严重创伤后马蹄足的有效性。回顾了近期采用补充改良手术的EGR技术,以提高其纠正畸形的能力,并提供避免并发症的信息。
研究对象为4例经至少3个月保守治疗无效的难治性、进行性、严重创伤后软组织马蹄足挛缩患者。排除标准为痉挛性挛缩,包括骨性马蹄足。1例腓肠肌型马蹄足患者单纯接受EGR作为直接矫正。3例腓肠肌-比目鱼肌型马蹄足患者先接受EGR矫正腓肠肌部分,然后采用改良经皮跟腱延长术(TAL)矫正任何残留畸形。前瞻性收集术前及术后各连续时期(1、3和6 - 12个月)的所有数据,包括踝关节背屈程度、美国矫形足踝协会(AOFAS)临床评分量表得分、视觉模拟量表-足踝(VAS-FA)得分以及任何相关并发症。术中,每次手术后立即记录踝关节背屈程度。
所有4例患者术中背屈平均增加35°±9.1°(范围:25° - 45°),3例接受EGR和改良TAL的患者分别为21.7°±10.4°(范围,10° - 30°)。术前及术后各连续时期踝关节背屈增加值、AOFAS评分和VAS-FA评分的改善情况存在显著差异(p<0.05)。无明显医源性并发症。
骨科医生较少遇到难治性、严重创伤后马蹄足。尽管这种情况罕见,导致本系列患者数量有限,但我们的结果表明,双切口EGR无论是否联合改良TAL,都是一种有前景的治疗方法,对于纠正这种棘手的畸形具有令人满意的有效性和较低的并发症风险。