Health Service and Population Research Department, King's College, London, UK.
Epidemiol Psychiatr Sci. 2012 Dec;21(4):393-9. doi: 10.1017/S2045796012000236. Epub 2012 Jun 13.
BACKGROUND.: Increasing therapeutic inpatient activities may improve the quality and outcomes of care. Evaluation of these interventions is necessary including assessment of cost-effectiveness. The aim of this paper is to describe the development and reliability of a tool to collect information on care contacts and therapeutic activities of patients on inpatient wards.
METHOD.: The development of the tool consisted of: 1) literature review, 2) interviews with staff, 3) expert consultation, 4) feasibility study, 5) focus groups with staff members, and 6) reliability tests. Service use data were collected with the tool and costs calculated.
RESULTS.: Service users' reported more use of activities than that contained in case notes during a 7-day period. This resulted in a cost difference of £10 per person. Case notes had more one-to-one nursing contacts, with a cost difference of £4 per person. One-day data showed less nurse contact time reported by participants compared to observational data (p < 0.001) but similar use of activities. Costs were £46 for the tool and £67 for the observational data.
CONCLUSIONS.: This tool is a good source of information on the number of activities attended by service users and contacts with psychiatrists. There is some disagreement with other sources of information on interactions between service users and nurses, possibly reflecting different definitions of a ‘meaningful contact’. This does not have a major impact on cost given that for much of the care received there is reasonable agreement.
增加治疗性住院活动可能会提高护理质量和结果。有必要评估这些干预措施,包括评估成本效益。本文的目的是描述一种收集住院患者护理接触和治疗活动信息的工具的开发和可靠性。
该工具的开发包括:1)文献回顾,2)与工作人员的访谈,3)专家咨询,4)可行性研究,5)与工作人员的焦点小组,以及 6)可靠性测试。使用该工具收集服务使用数据并计算成本。
服务使用者报告在 7 天内比病历中记录的活动多。这导致每人费用差异为 10 英镑。病历中记录了更多的一对一护理接触,每人费用差异为 4 英镑。与观察数据相比,参与者报告的一天内护理接触时间较少(p<0.001),但活动使用情况相似。该工具的成本为 46 英镑,观察数据的成本为 67 英镑。
该工具是服务使用者参加活动次数和与精神科医生接触次数的重要信息来源。与服务使用者和护士之间的互动的其他信息来源存在一些分歧,这可能反映了“有意义的接触”的不同定义。由于大部分护理都有合理的共识,因此这对成本的影响不大。