Rojvachiranonda Nond, Pyungtanasup Kasemsak, Siriwan Pichit, Mahatumarat Charan
Division of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Department of Surgery, King Chulalongkorn Memorial Hospital, Bangkok, Thailand.
J Craniofac Surg. 2012 Jul;23(4):1163-5. doi: 10.1097/SCS.0b013e31824e25e1.
Augmentation rhinoplasty is one of the most common cosmetic procedures done in Asia. A technique believed to be helpful in reducing complications is subperiosteal placement of silicone implant. A deeply placed implant should benefit from having thicker soft tissue coverage. Tough periosteal tissue is hoped to provide better implant fixation and prevent undesirable mobility. Experienced surgeons often claim that they can preserve the nasal periosteum and achieve complete implant coverage via nasal rim incision(s). However, success of implant placement and preservation of periosteal integrity after nasal augmentation has never been studied before.Nose augmentation with silicone implant was conducted in 12 fresh cadavers with the closed technique used in real practice. Open dissection of the nose was then carried out to verify implant position and the integrity of the periosteum. Factors that could affect the outcomes, including blade sizes of periosteal elevators, use of Aufricht retractor, and surgeon's experience, were analyzed.We found that all silicones could be implanted in the subperiosteal plane independent of instruments, surgeon's technique, and experience. Nonetheless, the covering nasal periosteum was always torn at its periphery and disconnected from the surrounding bone. As a result, lateral sides of the inserted silicones were not immediately covered with the periosteum.In conclusion, the surgeon's experience, the size of the periosteal elevator, and the Aufricht retractor did not affect the success of implant placement in the subperiosteal plane. Periosteal coverage was always incomplete and did not provide immediate implant fixation as previously understood.
隆鼻术是亚洲最常见的美容手术之一。一种被认为有助于减少并发症的技术是硅胶植入物的骨膜下放置。植入位置较深的植入物应有更厚的软组织覆盖,有望从中受益。坚硬的骨膜组织有望提供更好的植入物固定,并防止不必要的移动。经验丰富的外科医生常称,他们可以保留鼻骨膜,并通过鼻缘切口实现植入物的完全覆盖。然而,隆鼻术后植入物放置的成功率以及骨膜完整性的保留情况此前从未被研究过。
在12具新鲜尸体上采用实际操作中使用的闭合技术进行硅胶隆鼻。然后对鼻子进行开放解剖,以验证植入物位置和骨膜的完整性。分析了可能影响结果的因素,包括骨膜剥离子的刀片尺寸、Aufricht牵开器的使用以及外科医生的经验。
我们发现,所有硅胶都可以独立于器械、外科医生的技术和经验植入骨膜下平面。尽管如此,覆盖的鼻骨膜在其周边总是会撕裂,并与周围的骨组织分离。结果,插入的硅胶侧面没有立即被骨膜覆盖。
总之,外科医生的经验、骨膜剥离子的尺寸和Aufricht牵开器并不影响骨膜下平面植入物放置的成功率。骨膜覆盖总是不完整的,并且没有如之前所理解的那样提供立即的植入物固定。