Department of General Medicine, Niigata University Medical and Dental Hospital, 1−754 Asahimachi-dori, Chuo-ku, Niigata, Japan.
Allergol Int. 2012 Sep;61(3):475-87. doi: 10.2332/allergolint.11-OA-0413. Epub 2012 Jul 25.
Previous studies show that depression plays an important role in asthma. However, the association between asthma control and severity, and depression is inconclusive.
To investigate the association between asthma control and severity, and depression, we assessed differences in asthma control and asthma severity between groups with various grades of depressive state as defined by the PHQ-9 score using data from the Japanese version of Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (J-PHQ-9) and a questionnaire survey including the Asthma Control Test (ACT).
The ACT scores in the symptom-screen positive (SP) and major/other depressive disorder (MDD/ODD) group were significantly lower than those in the symptom-screen negative (SN) and non-MDD/ODD groups, respectively. The rate of step1 and of step 3 and 4 in the SP group were significantly lower and higher than those in the SN group, respectively. When the SP group was divided into three, that is minimal, mild, and more than mild (MTM) depressive state subgroups, the ACT scores in the mild and MTM depressive state subgroups were significantly lower than those in the minimal depressive state subgroup. When the MTM subgroup was divided into moderate, moderate-severe and severe depressive state groups, however, there was no significant variation in ACT score and asthma severity among these three depressive state groups.
This study is the first, large-scale investigation of the use of the J-PHQ-9 in asthma patients. Using the J-PHQ-9 and the questionnaire, there was a clear association between asthma control and severity, and depression. As the depression became more severe, the existence of other depression-associated factors unrelated to asthma control and severity might be assumed, although further investigation will be required.
先前的研究表明抑郁在哮喘中起着重要作用。然而,哮喘控制和严重程度与抑郁之间的关系尚无定论。
为了研究哮喘控制和严重程度与抑郁之间的关系,我们使用日本版患者健康问卷-9(J-PHQ-9)和包括哮喘控制测试(ACT)在内的问卷调查的数据,评估了 PHQ-9 评分定义的不同抑郁状态组之间的哮喘控制和哮喘严重程度差异。
在症状筛查阳性(SP)和主要/其他抑郁障碍(MDD/ODD)组中,ACT 评分明显低于症状筛查阴性(SN)和非 MDD/ODD 组。SP 组的第 1 步和第 3 步和第 4 步的比例明显低于 SN 组,而 SP 组的比例明显高于 SN 组。当 SP 组被分为三部分,即轻度、中度和重度(MTM)抑郁状态亚组时,轻度和 MTM 抑郁状态亚组的 ACT 评分明显低于轻度抑郁状态亚组。然而,当 MTM 亚组被分为中度、中度重度和重度抑郁状态组时,这三个抑郁状态组之间的 ACT 评分和哮喘严重程度没有明显变化。
这项研究是首次使用 J-PHQ-9 对哮喘患者进行的大规模调查。使用 J-PHQ-9 和问卷,哮喘控制和严重程度与抑郁之间存在明确的关联。随着抑郁的加重,可能存在与哮喘控制和严重程度无关的其他与抑郁相关的因素,尽管需要进一步的研究。