Immunology and Microbiology, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Eur Respir J. 2013 Apr;41(4):909-16. doi: 10.1183/09031936.00194311. Epub 2012 Aug 9.
The performance of QuantiFERON microtube (QFT-MT), using 0.9 mL blood, and QuantiFERON-TB Gold in-tube test (QFT-IT) (3 mL blood), for diagnosing tuberculosis (TB) was compared in children and adults in an endemic setting. In 152 children with suspected TB and 87 adults with confirmed TB, QFT-IT was compared with two QFT-MT concentrations (QFT-MT A and B). Proportions of positive and indeterminate results, interferon (IFN)-γ responses, interassay agreement and sensitivity were assessed. We found similar proportions of indeterminate results, levels of IFN-γ and comparable sensitivity. The interassay agreement was moderate in all children (QFT-IT versus QFT-MT A: 85%, k=0.44 and QFT-IT versus QFT-MT B: 88%, k=0.50) and adults (QFT-IT versus QFT-MT A: 88%, k=0.50 and QFT-IT versus QFT-MT B: 89%, k=0.49). Sensitivity was low (QFT-IT 23%, QFT-MT A 18% and B 19%) in children with confirmed or highly probable TB compared with adults (83%, 86% and 88%, respectively). The QFT-MT test can be reliably performed using less than one-third of the blood volume used in QFT-IT. The reduced volume may be useful for research and future diagnosis of paediatric TB. The poor sensitivity and high indeterminate rate of both IFN-γ release assays in severely ill children, with immature or impaired immunity in an endemic setting, warrants further investigations.
在一个流行地区,比较了使用 0.9 毫升血液的 QuantiFERON 微量管(QFT-MT)和使用 3 毫升血液的 QuantiFERON-TB Gold 管内试验(QFT-IT)检测儿童和成人结核病(TB)的性能。在 152 例疑似结核病的儿童和 87 例确诊结核病的成人中,将 QFT-IT 与两种 QFT-MT 浓度(QFT-MT A 和 B)进行了比较。评估了阳性和不确定结果的比例、干扰素(IFN)-γ 反应、批内一致性和敏感性。我们发现不确定结果的比例、IFN-γ 水平和相当的敏感性相似。所有儿童(QFT-IT 与 QFT-MT A:85%,k=0.44 和 QFT-IT 与 QFT-MT B:88%,k=0.50)和成人(QFT-IT 与 QFT-MT A:88%,k=0.50 和 QFT-IT 与 QFT-MT B:89%,k=0.49)的批内一致性为中等。与成人相比,确诊或高度疑似结核病的儿童(QFT-IT 23%,QFT-MT A 18%和 B 19%)的敏感性较低。QFT-MT 试验可以使用不到 QFT-IT 所用血液量的三分之一来可靠地进行。在流行地区,对于患有严重疾病且免疫功能不成熟或受损的儿童,减少体积可能对研究和未来的儿童结核病诊断有用。两种 IFN-γ 释放试验在严重疾病儿童中敏感性差和不确定率高,需要进一步研究。