Rhouma O, McMahon A D, Welbury R R
Department of Paediatric Dentistry, Glasgow Dental Hospital and School, Glasgow, UK.
Eur Arch Paediatr Dent. 2012 Aug;13(4):203-9. doi: 10.1007/BF03262871.
To identify early clinical variables that are most predictive of treatment outcome and to develop a model that will allow prediction of treatment outcomes based on these variables.
A dental trauma database was used to randomly identify patients who had received treatment for avulsed teeth between 1998 and 2007. A data extraction form was designed and completed for each tooth. Demographic, diagnostic and treatment information recorded in the patient's records, in addition to radiographs, were viewed retrospectively.
The significance and the predictive power for each early clinical variable were assessed using a univariate logistic regression model. Only significant variables (p<0.05) were considered eligible for the prediction model and a c-index was then constructed for their respective predictive power (0.5 = no predictive power, 1.0 = perfect prediction).
Of the original sample of 213 patients who had received treatment for avulsed teeth between 1998-2007 only 105 fulfilled the criteria for evaluation. Two models ('At first visit' and 'at initial treatment visits') were produced with a total of five variables that were significant and holding the greatest predictive power (high c-index): patient age (p=0.001, c=0.80); stage of root formation (p=0.001, c=0.76); storage medium (p=0.047, c=0.58); tooth mobility after dressing (p=0.001, c=0.70); and tooth mobility after splinting (p=0.003, c=0.70). These variables underwent multi-variate analysis and the final models had good predictive abilities (c-index of 0.80 and 0.74).
These predictive models based on patient age, stage of root formation, storage medium, tooth mobility after dressing and tooth mobility after splinting were shown to have high predictive value and will enable a clinician to estimate the long term prognosis of avulsed and replanted teeth. It will enable planning for further treatment with a realistic view of outcome at an early stage.
确定最能预测治疗结果的早期临床变量,并建立一个基于这些变量预测治疗结果的模型。
使用一个牙外伤数据库随机选取1998年至2007年间接受过牙齿脱位治疗的患者。为每颗牙齿设计并填写一份数据提取表。回顾性查看患者记录中除X光片外所记录的人口统计学、诊断和治疗信息。
使用单因素逻辑回归模型评估每个早期临床变量的显著性和预测能力。仅将显著变量(p<0.05)纳入预测模型,然后为其各自的预测能力构建c指数(0.5 = 无预测能力,1.0 = 完美预测)。
在1998 - 2007年间接受过牙齿脱位治疗的213例原始样本患者中,只有105例符合评估标准。生成了两个模型(“初次就诊时”和“初次治疗就诊时),共有五个变量具有显著性且预测能力最强(高c指数):患者年龄(p = 0.001,c = 0.80);牙根形成阶段(p = 0.001,c = 0.76);储存介质(p = 0.047,c = 0.58);包扎后牙齿松动度(p = (此处原文有误,应为p = 0.001),c = 0.70);夹板固定后牙齿松动度(p = 0.003,c = 0.70)。对这些变量进行多因素分析,最终模型具有良好的预测能力(c指数分别为0.80和0.74)。
这些基于患者年龄、牙根形成阶段、储存介质、包扎后牙齿松动度和夹板固定后牙齿松动度的预测模型显示出较高的预测价值,将使临床医生能够估计脱位再植牙的长期预后。它将有助于在早期阶段对治疗结果有一个现实的认识,从而规划进一步的治疗。