Andersson Jonas, Johansson Erik, Tölli Heikki
Department of Radiation Sciences, Radiation Physics, Umeå University, SE-901 85 Umeå, Sweden.
Med Phys. 2012 Aug;39(8):4775-87. doi: 10.1118/1.4736804.
The performance of liquid ionization chambers, which may prove to be useful tools in the field of radiation dosimetry, is based on several chamber and liquid specific characteristics. The present work investigates the performance of the PTW microLion liquid ionization chamber with respect to recombination losses and perturbations from ambient electric fields at various dose rates in continuous beams.
In the investigation, experiments were performed using two microLion chambers, containing isooctane (C(8)H(18)) and tetramethylsilane [Si(CH(3))(4)] as the sensitive media, and a NACP-02 monitor chamber. An initial activity of approximately 250 GBq (18)F was employed as the radiation source in the experiments. The initial dose rate in each measurement series was estimated to 1.0 Gy min(-1) by Monte Carlo simulations and the measurements were carried out during the decay of the radioactive source. In the investigation of general recombination losses, employing the two-dose-rate method for continuous beams, the liquid ionization chambers were operated at polarizing voltages 25, 50, 100, 150, 200, and 300 V. Furthermore, measurements were also performed at 500 V polarizing voltage in the investigation of the sensitivity of the microLion chamber to ambient electric fields.
The measurement results from the liquid ionization chambers, corrected for general recombination losses according to the two-dose-rate method for continuous beams, had a good agreement with the signal to dose linearity from the NACP-02 monitor chamber for general collection efficiencies above 70%. The results also displayed an agreement with the theoretical collection efficiencies according to the Greening theory, except for the liquid ionization chamber containing isooctane operated at 25 V. At lower dose rates, perturbations from ambient electric fields were found in the microLion chamber measurement results. Due to the perturbations, measurement results below an estimated dose rate of 0.2 Gy min(-1) were excluded from the present investigation of the general collection efficiency. The perturbations were found to be more pronounced when the chamber polarizing voltage was increased.
By using the two-dose-rate method for continuous beams, comparable corrected ionization currents from experiments in low and medium energy photon beams can be achieved. However, the valid range of general collection efficiencies has been found to vary in a comparison between experiments performed in continuous beams of 120 kVp x ray, and the present investigation of 511 keV annihilation photons. At very high dose rates in continuous beams, there are presently no methods that can be used to correct for general recombination losses and at low dose rates the microLion chamber may be perturbed by ambient electric fields. Increasing the chamber polarizing voltage, which diminishes the general recombination effect, was found to increase the microLion chamber sensitivity to ambient electric fields. Prudence is thus advised when employing the microLion chamber in radiation dosimetry, as ambient electric fields of the strength observed in the present work may be found in many common situations. Due to uncertainties in the theoretical basis for recombination losses in liquids, further studies on the underlying theories for the initial and general recombination effect are needed if liquid ionization chambers are to become a viable option in high precision radiation dosimetry.
液体电离室的性能基于多种室和液体的特定特性,这可能使其成为辐射剂量学领域有用的工具。本研究调查了PTW microLion液体电离室在连续束流中不同剂量率下的复合损失和来自环境电场的扰动性能。
在研究中,使用了两个装有异辛烷(C(8)H(18))和四甲基硅烷[Si(CH(3))(4)]作为灵敏介质的microLion室以及一个NACP - 02监测室进行实验。实验中使用初始活度约为250 GBq的(18)F作为辐射源。通过蒙特卡罗模拟估计每个测量系列的初始剂量率为1.0 Gy min(-1),测量在放射源衰变期间进行。在一般复合损失的研究中,采用连续束流的双剂量率方法,液体电离室在25、50、100、150、200和300 V的极化电压下运行。此外,在研究microLion室对环境电场的灵敏度时,也在500 V极化电压下进行了测量。
根据连续束流的双剂量率方法对液体电离室的测量结果进行一般复合损失校正后,对于一般收集效率高于70%的情况,与NACP - 02监测室的信号与剂量线性度有良好的一致性。结果还与根据格林理论的理论收集效率一致,但装有异辛烷的液体电离室在25 V下运行的情况除外。在较低剂量率下,在microLion室测量结果中发现了来自环境电场的扰动。由于这些扰动,本研究对一般收集效率的调查中排除了估计剂量率低于0.2 Gy min(-1)的测量结果。当室极化电压增加时,发现扰动更为明显。
通过使用连续束流的双剂量率方法,可以在低能和中能光子束实验中获得可比的校正电离电流。然而,发现在120 kVp x射线连续束实验与本研究的511 keV湮灭光子实验的比较中,一般收集效率的有效范围有所不同。在连续束流的非常高剂量率下,目前没有可用于校正一般复合损失的方法,而在低剂量率下,microLion室可能会受到环境电场的扰动。发现增加室极化电压虽然减少了一般复合效应,但会增加microLion室对环境电场的灵敏度。因此,在辐射剂量学中使用microLion室时应谨慎,因为在本研究中观察到的这种强度的环境电场可能在许多常见情况下出现。由于液体中复合损失理论基础的不确定性,如果液体电离室要成为高精度辐射剂量学中的可行选择,需要对初始和一般复合效应的基础理论进行进一步研究。