School of Psychology, Cardiff University, UK.
Psychol Psychother. 2012 Jun;85(2):150-62. doi: 10.1111/j.2044-8341.2011.02024.x. Epub 2011 Jun 16.
Anomalous experiences occur in many psychiatric conditions, but are also reported by non-patients. Given the continuum account of psychiatric symptoms and reports of dissociation between delusions and anomalous experiences, we predicted that anomalous experiences in a large non-clinical sample would (1) associate with delusion-like beliefs but not with socio-cultural beliefs and (2) that anomalous experiences would also show examples of dissociation with anomalous beliefs. A particular focus was the association between beliefs and experiences theoretically predicted to co-occur in Capgras syndrome.
The study examined the distribution and correlates of differential levels of self-reported anomalous experience in a British sample of 1,000 individuals.
Anomalous experiences were found to be relatively common in the general population and were reported (occurring sometimes/often) by 48% of the sample. Being female and endorsing a non-Christian religion were the only two demographic factors related to higher experience scores. Significant relationships were found between anomalous experiences and anomalous beliefs (i.e., delusion-like and paranormal/religious), but not general societal beliefs. Dissociations between anomalous experiences and anomalous beliefs also were present but not common. No significant relationship was found between Capgras-type beliefs and experiences.
This large scale study demonstrated significant association between anomalous experiences and anomalous beliefs in the general population. The relationship was not, however present in all cases similar to cases reported in the clinical literature.
异常体验发生在许多精神疾病中,但也有非患者报告。鉴于精神症状的连续体和妄想与异常体验之间分离的报道,我们预测在大样本非临床人群中,异常体验将:(1)与类似妄想的信念相关,但与社会文化信念无关;(2)异常体验也将表现出与异常信念分离的例子。特别关注的是卡普格拉综合征中理论上预测会共同出现的信念和体验之间的关联。
本研究考察了英国 1000 名个体中自我报告异常体验的不同水平的分布和相关性。
异常体验在普通人群中相对常见,有 48%的样本报告有时/经常出现。女性和不信仰基督教是与更高体验得分相关的唯二两个人口统计学因素。异常体验与异常信念(即类似妄想和超自然/宗教)之间存在显著关系,但与一般社会信念无关。异常体验和异常信念之间也存在分离,但并不常见。卡普格拉类型的信念和体验之间没有显著关系。
这项大规模研究表明,在普通人群中,异常体验与异常信念之间存在显著关联。然而,这种关系并非在所有情况下都存在,与临床文献中报道的情况并不完全相同。