Department of Surgery, University of Mississippi Medical Center, Jackson, MS, USA.
J Surg Educ. 2012 Sep-Oct;69(5):575-9. doi: 10.1016/j.jsurg.2012.05.005. Epub 2012 Jul 7.
The surgical resident experience regarding open surgical procedures and techniques is being significantly limited by the maturation of minimally invasive surgery (MIS) and duty-hour restrictions. MIS has replaced many open procedures as the current standard of care. As MIS progresses, the surgical residents' access to open surgical techniques will become significantly limited by the lack of exposure to common open operations.
The Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) database was retrospectively reviewed to quantify and categorize resident experience in self-reported surgical procedures. The United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) database was retrospectively reviewed to determine the amount of organ transplants and procurements performed during the study period. Data from 1999-2000 and 2008-2009 were collected and compared.
There were dramatic changes between the time periods regarding the transition from the open to the laparoscopic approach for multiple operations. In 2008, there were 23,276 transplanted organs and 29,077 organs procured (7990 multi-organ procurements). However, the graduating general surgery chief residents reported doing an average of 2 organ procurements and 7 organ transplantations over a 5-year period. This provides the opportunity for each graduating chief resident to perform 38 more procurements during their residency.
It is imperative for surgical educators to find solutions to safely train the future general surgery residents to perform more surgical techniques in less time. One solution to this problem may lie within the field of organ transplantation and procurement. The field of organ transplantation and procurement may be an untapped resource for valuable exposure to the basic principles of open surgical techniques that are declining due to the advancement of MIS and mandated duty-hour restrictions.
微创手术(MIS)的成熟和工作时间限制,极大地限制了外科住院医师在开放性手术程序和技术方面的经验。MIS 已经取代了许多开放性手术,成为当前的治疗标准。随着 MIS 的发展,由于缺乏对常见开放性手术的接触,外科住院医师获得开放性手术技术的机会将大大受限。
回顾性审查了研究生医学教育认证委员会(ACGME)数据库,以量化和分类住院医师自我报告手术程序的经验。回顾性审查了器官共享联合网络(UNOS)数据库,以确定研究期间进行的器官移植和采集数量。收集了 1999-2000 年和 2008-2009 年的数据并进行了比较。
在多个手术从开放性手术向腹腔镜手术转变方面,两个时间段之间存在显著变化。2008 年,有 23276 个移植器官和 29077 个器官采集(7990 个多器官采集)。然而,普通外科住院医师总住院医师报告在 5 年内平均进行 2 次器官采集和 7 次器官移植。这为每位即将毕业的总住院医师提供了在住院期间多进行 38 次采集的机会。
外科教育工作者必须找到解决方案,以安全地培训未来的普通外科住院医师,使其在更短的时间内掌握更多的手术技术。这个问题的解决方案之一可能在于器官移植和采集领域。器官移植和采集领域可能是一个未开发的资源,可以为基本的开放性手术技术提供宝贵的接触机会,这些技术由于 MIS 的进步和强制性工作时间限制而逐渐减少。