Yadav K Shailaja, Gonuguntla Sudhir, Ealla Kranti Kiran Reddy, Velidandla Surekha Reddy, Reddy C R Charan, Prasanna M D, Bommu Sanjay Reddy
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery Lenora Dental College, Rajahmundry, Andhra Pradesh, India.
J Contemp Dent Pract. 2012 May 1;13(3):339-44. doi: 10.5005/jp-journals-10024-1148.
Mitotic counting is often used for classification, grading and prognosis of tumors. The count usually stands as a decision point for treatment as well. The easiest way of counting the number of mitoses is done by screening routine H&E stained slides. However, for proper mitotic counting, certain strict protocols should be taken into consideration. This study on 30 cases of different grades of oral squamous cell carcinoma was undertaken to determine the interobserver variations in two different groups: Group1 (A1, A2), who were given certain criteria to be followed during the counting of the mitotic figures and group 2 investigators (B1, B2) who were unaware of such criteria. The paired t-test gives a correlation of 0.988 and a significant difference of 0.000 between the two investigators in group 1. The correlation was 0.650 with a significant difference of 0.058 between two investigators in-group 2, indicating that group 1 observers exhibit good interobserver agreement. The results emphasize that following of strict protocols are of great help in determining the accuracy of mitotic counting.
有丝分裂计数常用于肿瘤的分类、分级和预后评估。该计数通常也是治疗的决策依据。计数有丝分裂数量的最简单方法是筛查常规苏木精-伊红(H&E)染色切片。然而,为了进行准确的有丝分裂计数,应考虑某些严格的方案。本研究对30例不同分级的口腔鳞状细胞癌进行了分析,以确定两组观察者之间的差异:第1组(A1、A2),在计数有丝分裂图像时遵循特定标准;第2组研究者(B1、B2),不知道这些标准。配对t检验显示,第1组的两位研究者之间的相关性为0.988,显著性差异为0.000。第2组的两位研究者之间的相关性为0.650,显著性差异为0.058,这表明第1组观察者之间具有良好的观察者间一致性。结果强调,遵循严格的方案对确定有丝分裂计数的准确性有很大帮助。