Digestive Diseases Research Institute, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Arch Iran Med. 2012 Sep;15(9):531-7.
Short term randomized trials have shown the effectiveness of a fixed dose combination therapy (known as Polypill) on reducing blood pressure and serum cholesterol but the impact of Polypill on cardiovascular disease risk or mortality has not yet been directly investigated. Previous studies combined the effects of each component assuming a multiplicative joint risk model that may have led to overestimating the combined effects. We conducted an updated meta-analysis of randomized trials of anti-hypertensives, and aspirin. We used the estimated effect sizes applying a more conservative assumption to estimate the number of ischemic heart disease (IHD) and stroke deaths that could have been averted by Polypill in Iranians aged 55 years or older in 2006.
We searched Medline and reviewed previous meta-analyses to select randomized trials on Angiotensin Converting Enzyme-inhibitors, thiazides, aspirin, and statins. We used a random-effects model to pool relative risks for each component and estimated the joint relative risks using multiplicative and additive assumptions for 4 combinations of Polypill components. We used age- and cause-specific mortality, separately by gender, and estimated the number of preventable deaths from IHD and stroke.
Under the additive joint RR assumption, the standard Polypill formulation was estimated to prevent 28500 (95% CI: 21700, 34100) IHD deaths and 12700 (95% CI: 8800, 15900) stroke deaths. Removing aspirin from the combination decreased preventable IHD deaths by 15% under the additive assumption (5600 deaths) and by 21% under the multiplicative assumption (6800 deaths) and reduced preventable stroke deaths under both additive and multiplicative assumptions by 3% (300 deaths). There was no significant difference between Polypill combinations with anti-hypertensive agents in full-dose or half-dose.
Polypill can prevent a large number of IHD and stroke deaths in Iran. The cost-effectiveness, feasibility, and acceptability of this prevention strategy remain to be investigated.
短期随机试验表明,固定剂量联合治疗(即 Polypill)可有效降低血压和血清胆固醇,但 Polypill 对心血管疾病风险或死亡率的影响尚未直接研究过。先前的研究将每个成分的效果结合起来,假设联合风险模型是乘法的,这可能导致对联合效果的高估。我们对抗高血压药物和阿司匹林的随机试验进行了更新的荟萃分析。我们应用更保守的假设来估计每个成分的效果大小,以估计在 2006 年伊朗 55 岁及以上人群中,Polypill 可以预防的缺血性心脏病 (IHD) 和中风死亡人数。
我们搜索了 Medline 并回顾了以前的荟萃分析,以选择血管紧张素转换酶抑制剂、噻嗪类、阿司匹林和他汀类药物的随机试验。我们使用随机效应模型来汇总每个成分的相对风险,并使用乘法和加法假设来估计 Polypill 成分的 4 种组合的联合相对风险。我们按性别分别使用年龄和病因特异性死亡率来估计 IHD 和中风的可预防死亡人数。
在加法联合 RR 假设下,标准 Polypill 配方估计可预防 28500 例(95%CI:21700,34100)IHD 死亡和 12700 例(95%CI:8800,15900)中风死亡。在加法假设下,从组合中去除阿司匹林会使可预防的 IHD 死亡减少 15%(5600 例死亡),在乘法假设下减少 21%(6800 例死亡),并且在加法和乘法假设下都减少了 3%(300 例死亡)可预防的中风死亡。全剂量或半剂量的抗高血压药物与 Polypill 组合之间没有显著差异。
Polypill 可以预防伊朗大量的 IHD 和中风死亡。这种预防策略的成本效益、可行性和可接受性仍有待研究。