Departamento de Botânica, Universidade Federal de São Carlos, PO Box 676, São Carlos, SP, 13565-905, Brazil.
Oecologia. 2013 Feb;171(2):487-94. doi: 10.1007/s00442-012-2431-8. Epub 2012 Aug 25.
Intraspecific trait variability plays a fundamental role in community structure and dynamics; however, few studies have evaluated its relative importance to the overall response of communities to environmental pressures. Since fire is considered a key factor in Neotropical savannas, we investigated to what extent the functional effects of fire in a Brazilian savanna occurs via intra- or interspecific trait variability. We sampled 12 traits in communities subjected to three fire regimes in the last 12 years: annual, biennial, and protected. To evaluate fire's relative effects, we fitted a general linear mixed models with species as random and fire as fixed factors, using: (1) all species in the communities (i.e., considering intra- and interspecific variabilities); (2) 18 species common to all fire regimes (i.e., intraspecific variability only); and (3) all species with their overall average trait values (i.e., interspecific variability only). We assessed the relative role of intra- or interspecific variability by comparing the significance of each trait in the three analyses. We also compared the within and between fire variabilities with a variance component analysis. Five traits presented larger intraspecific than interspecific variability, and the main effect of fire occurred at the intraspecific level. These results confirm that it is important to consider intraspecific variability to fully understand fire-prone communities. Moreover, trait variability was larger within than among fire regimes. Thus, fire may act more as an external filter, preventing some of the species from the regional pool from colonizing the cerrado, than as an internal factor structuring the already filtered cerrado communities.
种内性状变异性对群落结构和动态起着至关重要的作用;然而,很少有研究评估其对群落整体对环境压力响应的相对重要性。由于火被认为是新热带草原的关键因素,我们调查了火在巴西草原中的功能效应是通过种内还是种间性状变异性来实现的。我们在过去 12 年中经历了三种火灾制度的群落中采样了 12 种性状:一年生、二年生和受保护的。为了评估火灾的相对影响,我们使用物种作为随机因素和火灾作为固定因素拟合了一个广义线性混合模型,包括:(1)群落中的所有物种(即,考虑种内和种间变异性);(2)所有火灾制度中都有的 18 个常见物种(即,仅种内变异性);(3)所有物种及其整体平均性状值(即,仅种间变异性)。我们通过比较三种分析中每个性状的显著性来评估种内或种间变异性的相对作用。我们还通过方差分量分析比较了火灾内和火灾间的变异性。有 5 个性状表现出比种间变异性更大的种内变异性,火灾的主要效应发生在种内水平。这些结果证实,考虑种内变异性对于全面理解易火群落是很重要的。此外,性状变异性在火灾内比火灾间更大。因此,火可能更像是一种外部过滤器,阻止了一些来自区域库的物种在塞拉多地区定居,而不是作为一种结构已经过滤过的塞拉多群落的内部因素。