Haas Jason M, Gundrum Jacob D, Rathgaber Scott W
Department of Medical Education, Gundersen Lutheran Medical Foundation, La Crosse, Wis, USA.
WMJ. 2012 Aug;111(4):161-5.
Recent findings suggest that time to endoscopy is prolonged in patients admitted on the weekend with upper gastrointestinal hemorrhage (UGIH), which may result in increased adverse outcomes. This study was designed to determine if these findings hold true for a community gastroenterology practice.
This retrospective study reviewed patients admitted to a community teaching hospital from January 1, 2008, through October 31, 2008 with the primary diagnosis of UGIH. UGIH was further defined as acute variceal hemorrhage (AVH) or non-variceal hemorrhage (NVUGIH). The primary groups were based on weekend vs weekday admission. Time to endoscopy, adverse outcomes, presenting symptom, and length of stay were analyzed.
One hundred seventy-four patients were included (50 weekend; 124 weekday). Most patients (94.25%) received upper endoscopy within 24 hours of admission. Mean time to endoscopy was shorter for weekend admission compared to weekday (7.52 hours vs 10.82 hours; P=0.012) for the entire group. No statistically significant difference was detected in AVH patients (6.37 hours vs 4.37 hours; P=0.09), but a difference was observed in the NVUGIH group (7.65 hours vs 11.45 hours, P=0.015). Adverse outcomes were not associated with weekend admission (P=0.583). There was no difference in mean length of stay (3.08 days vs 3.85 days; P=0.131) or mean units of blood transfused (2.44 units vs 2.07 units, P=0.417) between admission groups.
Patients admitted to this community teaching hospital with UGIH on the weekend did not experience delayed endoscopy, increased adverse outcomes, or longer length of stay compared to those admitted on a weekday. The previously reported "weekend effect" was not observed. In fact, patients admitted with NVUGIH on the weekend received upper endoscopy earlier than patients admitted during the week.
近期研究结果表明,周末因上消化道出血(UGIH)入院的患者接受内镜检查的时间延长,这可能导致不良后果增加。本研究旨在确定这些结果在社区胃肠病学实践中是否成立。
这项回顾性研究对2008年1月1日至2008年10月31日入住社区教学医院且初步诊断为UGIH的患者进行了回顾。UGIH进一步定义为急性静脉曲张出血(AVH)或非静脉曲张出血(NVUGIH)。主要分组基于周末入院与工作日入院。分析了内镜检查时间、不良后果、首发症状和住院时间。
共纳入174例患者(50例周末入院;124例工作日入院)。大多数患者(94.25%)在入院后24小时内接受了上消化道内镜检查。整个组中,周末入院患者的平均内镜检查时间比工作日短(7.52小时对10.82小时;P = 0.012)。AVH患者中未检测到统计学显著差异(6.37小时对4.37小时;P = 0.09),但在NVUGIH组中观察到差异(7.65小时对11.45小时,P = 0.015)。不良后果与周末入院无关(P = 0.583)。入院组之间的平均住院时间(3.08天对3.85天;P = 0.131)或平均输血单位数(2.44单位对2.07单位,P = 0.417)没有差异。
与工作日入院的患者相比,周末因UGIH入住该社区教学医院的患者未出现内镜检查延迟、不良后果增加或住院时间延长的情况。未观察到先前报道的“周末效应”。事实上,周末因NVUGIH入院的患者比一周内其他时间入院的患者更早接受了上消化道内镜检查。