Pierrart J, Bourgade P, Mamane W, Rousselon T, Masmejean E H
Unité de chirurgie de la main et des nerfs périphériques, hôpital Européens Georges-Pompidou (HEGP), université Paris-Descartes, Sorbonne Paris Cité, Assistance publique-Hôpitaux de Paris (AP-HP), Paris cedex, France.
Chir Main. 2012 Sep;31(4):188-94. doi: 10.1016/j.main.2012.07.011. Epub 2012 Aug 14.
In case of posttraumatic radiocarpal destruction, failure of first row carpectomy or partial arthrodesis, there are two options, total prosthesis of the wrist or panarthrodesis. Both solutions have limitations. The aim of our study was to evaluate an alternative therapy: interposition arthroplasty with pyrocarbon implant at follow-up of minimum 6months.
This is a retrospective monocentric study with clinical and radiological evaluation. This study includes 11 patients with a mean age of 55.2years. There were four failures of first row carpectomy, a failure of partial arthrodesis, a case of post-infection osteoarthritis, four cases of stage IV SNAC wrists and one siliconitis after a scaphoid implant.
At the average follow-up of 11 months, pain was improved in nine cases. The average flexion was 36.5° and average extension, 35°. The average strength was 8.3kg. Two implant dislocations occurred, only one required second look surgery for implant replacement. However, in this patient, pain remained severe and required panarthrodesis. In another patient, a second panarthrodesis was performed for resistant pain.
The interposition arthroplasty with pyrocarbon seems to give encouraging results as an alternative therapy. It gives satisfactory mobility, pain relief, but moderate strength. It has the advantages of a simple technique and does not preclude manual activities. A long-term validation is, of course, necessary.
对于创伤后桡腕关节破坏、一期腕骨切除术失败或部分关节融合术失败的情况,有两种选择,即全腕关节置换或全关节融合术。这两种解决方案都有局限性。我们研究的目的是评估一种替代疗法:使用热解碳植入物进行间置关节成形术,并进行至少6个月的随访。
这是一项回顾性单中心研究,包括临床和影像学评估。本研究纳入了11例患者,平均年龄为55.2岁。其中有4例一期腕骨切除术失败、1例部分关节融合术失败、1例感染后骨关节炎、4例IV期舟月骨塌陷性骨关节炎(SNAC)腕以及1例舟骨植入术后硅沉着病。
平均随访11个月时,9例患者疼痛得到改善。平均屈曲度为36.5°,平均伸展度为35°。平均握力为8.3千克。发生了2例植入物脱位,仅1例需要再次手术更换植入物。然而,该患者疼痛仍然严重,需要进行全关节融合术。另一例患者因顽固性疼痛进行了二次全关节融合术。
热解碳间置关节成形术作为一种替代疗法似乎能取得令人鼓舞的结果。它能提供令人满意的活动度、缓解疼痛,但握力中等。该技术具有操作简单的优点,且不影响手部活动。当然,还需要长期验证。