International Health Regulations Coordination Department, World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland.
Influenza Other Respir Viruses. 2013 Jul;7(4):604-21. doi: 10.1111/irv.12002. Epub 2012 Sep 18.
Annual influenza vaccination rates among hospital healthcare workers (HCW) are almost universally low despite recommendations from WHO and public health authorities in many countries. To assist in the development of successful vaccination programmes, we reviewed studies where interventions aimed to increase the uptake of influenza vaccination among hospital HCW. We searched PUBMED from 1990 up to December 2011 for publications with predetermined search strategies and of pre-defined criteria for inclusion or exclusion. We evaluated a large number of 'intervention programmes' each employing one or more 'intervention components' or strategies, such as easy access to vaccine or educational activities, with the goal to raise influenza vaccine uptake rates in hospital HCW during one influenza season. Included studies reported results of intervention programmes and compared the uptake with the season prior to the intervention (historical control) or to another intervention programme within the same season that started from the same set of baseline activities. Twenty-five studies performed in eight countries met our selection criteria and described 45 distinct intervention programmes. Most studies used their own facility as historical control and evaluated only one season. The following elements were used in intervention programmes that increased vaccine uptake: provision of free vaccine, easy access to the vaccine (e.g. through mobile carts or on-site vaccination), knowledge and behaviour modification through educational activities and/or reminders and/or incentives, management or organizational changes, such as the assignment of personnel dedicated to the intervention programme, long-term implementation of the strategy, requiring active declination and mandatory immunization policies. The number of these components applied appeared to be proportional to the increase in uptake. If influenza uptake in hospital HCW is to be increased on sustained basis, hospital managers need to be committed to conduct a well-designed long-term intervention programme that includes a variety of co-ordinated managerial and organizational elements.
尽管世界卫生组织和许多国家的公共卫生部门都提出了建议,但医院医护人员(HCW)的年度流感疫苗接种率几乎普遍较低。为了协助制定成功的疫苗接种计划,我们回顾了旨在提高医院 HCW 流感疫苗接种率的干预研究。我们在 1990 年至 2011 年 12 月期间,通过预定的搜索策略和明确的纳入或排除标准,在 PUBMED 上搜索了出版物。我们评估了大量的“干预计划”,每个计划都采用了一种或多种“干预组成部分”或策略,例如方便获得疫苗或教育活动,目的是在一个流感季节提高医院 HCW 的流感疫苗接种率。纳入的研究报告了干预计划的结果,并将接种率与干预前的季节(历史对照)或同一季节内的另一个干预计划进行了比较,后者是从同一组基线活动开始的。在八个国家进行的 25 项研究符合我们的选择标准,并描述了 45 个不同的干预计划。大多数研究都将自己的机构作为历史对照,并仅评估了一个季节。在增加疫苗接种率的干预计划中使用了以下要素:免费提供疫苗、方便获得疫苗(例如通过移动推车或现场接种)、通过教育活动和/或提醒和/或激励措施改变知识和行为、管理或组织变革,例如指定专门负责干预计划的人员、长期实施策略、要求主动拒绝和强制免疫政策。应用这些要素的数量似乎与接种率的增加成正比。如果要持续提高医院 HCW 的流感接种率,医院管理人员需要承诺开展设计良好的长期干预计划,其中包括各种协调的管理和组织要素。