Department of Anesthesia and Pain, Lille, France.
Pain Physician. 2012 Sep-Oct;15(5):395-403.
Ziconotide is a new analgesic agent administered intrathecally. It is challenging to use and can induce several and sometimes serious adverse events. A low initial dosage followed by slow titration may reduce serious adverse events.
To determine whether a low starting dosage of ziconotide, followed by slow titration, decreases the incidence of major adverse events associated with ziconotide when used for intractable cancer pain.
Observational cohort study.
Three French cancer centers.
Patients with incurable cancer causing chronic pain rated above 6/10 on a numerical scale while receiving high-dose opioid therapy (more than 200 mg/d of oral morphine equivalent) and/or exhibiting severe opioid-related adverse events received intrathecal infusions of ziconotide combined with morphine, ropivacaine, and clonidine.
Seventy-seven patients were included. Adverse events were recorded in 57% of them; moderate adverse events occurred in 51%. Adverse events required treatment discontinuation in 7 (9%) including 5 (6%) for whom a causal role for ziconotide was highly likely; among them 4 (5%) were serious. All patients experienced a significant and lasting decrease in pain intensity (by 48%) in response to intrathecal analgesic therapy that included ziconotide.
Limitations include the nonrandomized, observational nature of the study. Determining the relative contributions of each drug to adverse events was difficult, and some of the adverse events manifested as clinical symptoms of a subjective nature.
The rates of minor and moderate adverse events were consistent with previous reports. However, the rate of serious adverse events was substantially lower. Our study confirms the efficacy of intrathecal analgesia with ziconotide for relieving refractory cancer pain. These results indicate that multimodal intrathecal analgesia in patients with cancer pain should include ziconotide from the outset in order to provide time for subsequent slow titration.
地诺帕明是一种新的鞘内镇痛药物。它的使用具有挑战性,并且可能会引起多种,有时甚至是严重的不良反应。采用低起始剂量并缓慢滴定可能会降低严重不良反应的发生风险。
确定鞘内给予地诺帕明时,采用低起始剂量并缓慢滴定是否可以降低与地诺帕明相关的严重不良反应的发生率,从而治疗难治性癌痛。
观察性队列研究。
法国的 3 个癌症中心。
患有无法治愈的癌症且慢性疼痛评分高于 6/10(数字评分量表)的患者正在接受高剂量阿片类药物治疗(口服吗啡等效物超过 200 mg/d)和/或出现严重的阿片类药物相关不良反应,他们接受地诺帕明联合吗啡、罗哌卡因和可乐定鞘内输注。
共纳入 77 例患者。57%的患者出现了不良反应,其中 51%为中度不良反应。7 例(9%)因不良反应而停止治疗,其中 5 例(6%)高度怀疑与地诺帕明相关;其中 4 例(5%)为严重不良反应。所有患者接受鞘内镇痛治疗后,疼痛强度均显著且持久地降低(48%),该治疗包括地诺帕明。
研究存在非随机、观察性的局限性。确定每种药物对不良反应的相对贡献较为困难,部分不良反应表现为具有主观性质的临床症状。
本研究中轻度和中度不良反应的发生率与既往报道一致,但严重不良反应的发生率显著降低。本研究证实了鞘内地诺帕明治疗难治性癌痛的疗效。这些结果表明,对于癌症疼痛患者的鞘内多模式镇痛治疗,应从一开始就包括地诺帕明,以便为随后的缓慢滴定留出时间。