Swamy G G, Madhuravani S, Swamy G M
Department of Pathology, Konaseema Institute of Medical Sciences, Amalapuram, Andhra Pradesh, India.
Nepal Med Coll J. 2011 Dec;13(4):289-92.
To evaluate the accuracy and efficacy of fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) in the diagnosis of Thyroid gland enlargements. A retrospective analysis was done at Department of Pathology, Government Medical College and General Hospital, Anantapur, Andhra Pradesh, India. One hundred and fifty cases were included in this study. However in 10 cases aspirate was unsatisfactory and in 20 cases surgery was not performed and these cases were excluded from study. A total of 120 cases included in the final study. Detailed history, physical examination, routine investigations and other details of 120 patients were collected. FNAC with minimum two passes were performed in each case. Staining done with Haematoxylin and Eosin stain and Papanicolaou stains. FNAC smears and histopathology slides were reviewed. Among 120 cases 100 (83.66%) were reported cytologically as benign and 20 (16.66%) were malignant. But histologically 98 (81.66%) were benign and 22 (18.33%) were malignant. Commonest benign lesion of thyroid in both cytology and histology was nodular colloid goiter. Follicular adenoma was the second commonest one. Among malignant conditions papillary carcinoma was the commonest one in our FNAC samples, follicular carcinoma was the commonest in our histopathology samples. Four cases of false positive and 6 cases of false negative were observed. Sampling errors were mainly responsible for these false negative diagnoses. FNAC showed an accuracy of 96.6%, sensitivity 75%, specificity 95.83%, positive predicative value (PPV) 81.81% and negative predicative value (NPV) of 93.81%. Our results were similar to other international studies and suggest that FNAC is more specific and sensitive in detecting thyroid malignancy. Therefore its useas a reliable diagnostic test cannot be over emphasized. FNAC is an accurate and reliable diagnostic tool to evaluate the cause of Thyroid gland enlargements provided strict adherence to adequacy criteria are maintained.
评估细针穿刺细胞学检查(FNAC)在诊断甲状腺肿大方面的准确性和有效性。在印度安得拉邦阿南塔布尔政府医学院及综合医院病理科进行了一项回顾性分析。本研究纳入了150例病例。然而,10例抽吸物不满意,20例未进行手术,这些病例被排除在研究之外。最终研究共纳入120例病例。收集了120例患者的详细病史、体格检查、常规检查及其他详细信息。对每例患者至少进行两次穿刺的FNAC检查。采用苏木精和伊红染色及巴氏染色。对FNAC涂片和组织病理学切片进行复查。120例病例中,100例(83.66%)细胞学报告为良性,20例(16.66%)为恶性。但组织学上98例(81.66%)为良性,22例(18.33%)为恶性。细胞学和组织学中甲状腺最常见的良性病变是结节性胶样甲状腺肿。滤泡性腺瘤是第二常见的。在恶性病变中,乳头状癌在我们的FNAC样本中最常见,滤泡癌在我们的组织病理学样本中最常见。观察到4例假阳性和6例假阴性病例。抽样误差是这些假阴性诊断的主要原因。FNAC的准确率为96.6%,敏感性为75%,特异性为95.83%,阳性预测值(PPV)为81.81%,阴性预测值(NPV)为93.81%。我们的结果与其他国际研究相似,表明FNAC在检测甲状腺恶性肿瘤方面更具特异性和敏感性。因此,其作为一种可靠诊断试验的作用再怎么强调也不为过。只要严格遵守充分性标准,FNAC就是评估甲状腺肿大病因的准确可靠的诊断工具。