Dabrowski Marek, Parnowski Tadeusz
Oddział Chorób Afektywnych, II Klinika Psychiatryczna, IPiN w Warszawie.
Psychiatr Pol. 2012 May-Jun;46(3):345-60.
The aim of the study was to assess efficacy and safety of electroconvulsive therapy.
43 patients included into the study were hospitalised in The Institute of Psychiatry and Neurology and received all together over 400 bilateral electroconvulsive procedures. Most of the patients (N = 25) were qualified for electroconvulsive therapy due to treatment resistant depression (58.1%). Six patients: 2 with catatonia and 4 with depression had life saving indications for electroconvulsive therapy. Three patients (7%) were excluded from electroconvulsive therapy, following 1 or 2 electroconvulsive procedures. Forty patients continued electroconvulsive therapy.
There were no complications and serious adverse events in patients who continued electroconvulsive therapy. Generally, electroconvulsive therapy was well tolerated and treatment had been cut down in only one case due to adverse events and high risk related to the procedure. Transient cardiac arrhythmias (10% of patients) were the most often occurring adverse events and patients (35%) mostly reported headaches. We observed remission in 22 patients (58%) and improvement in 14 patients (35%) following electroconvulsive treatment. Only 4 patients (10%) had no benefit after a series of electroconvulsive procedures. Electroconvulsive treatment was most effective in patients with catatonia (80% patients had full recovery) and in depressive patients with bipolar disorder (73% patients had full recovery).
Electroconvulsive procedures were safe and effective. Electroconvulsive treatment was most effective in catatonic patients with schizophrenia and in depressive patients with bipolar disorder.
本研究旨在评估电休克治疗的疗效和安全性。
纳入本研究的43例患者在精神病学与神经病学研究所住院,共接受了400多次双侧电休克治疗。大多数患者(N = 25)因难治性抑郁症(58.1%)符合电休克治疗条件。6例患者:2例患有紧张症,4例患有抑郁症,有进行电休克治疗的挽救生命指征。3例患者(7%)在接受1或2次电休克治疗后被排除在电休克治疗之外。40例患者继续接受电休克治疗。
继续接受电休克治疗的患者未出现并发症和严重不良事件。总体而言,电休克治疗耐受性良好,仅1例因不良事件和与治疗相关的高风险而减少了治疗。短暂性心律失常(10%的患者)是最常出现的不良事件,患者(35%)大多报告有头痛。电休克治疗后,我们观察到22例患者(58%)缓解,14例患者(35%)改善。只有4例患者(10%)在接受一系列电休克治疗后没有获益。电休克治疗在患有紧张症的患者(80%的患者完全康复)和患有双相情感障碍的抑郁症患者(73%的患者完全康复)中最有效。
电休克治疗安全有效。电休克治疗在患有精神分裂症的紧张症患者和患有双相情感障碍的抑郁症患者中最有效。