Department of Psychiatry, National Defense Medical College, 3-2 Namiki, Tokorozawa, Saitama 359-8513, Japan.
Asian J Psychiatr. 2011 Dec;4(4):293-6. doi: 10.1016/j.ajp.2011.10.003. Epub 2011 Dec 6.
Patients with anxiety disorder (AD) are more likely to be concurrently comorbid with other ADs or major depressive disorder (MDD). However, it is unknown whether such patients show more severe anxiety symptoms than patients with single AD. We compared anxiety severity among patients with single AD, multiple ADs, and multiple ADs plus MDD. Subjects were 136 consecutive outpatients with any AD who were comprehensively diagnosed. Symptom severity of panic disorder (PD), social anxiety disorder (SAD), obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), and generalized anxiety disorder (GAD) was measured using self-rating questionnaires, and the scores were compared among the 3 comorbidity conditions (single AD vs. multiple ADs vs. multiple ADs plus MDD). PD and SAD scores in the multiple ADs and the multiple ADs plus MDD conditions were significantly greater than the scores in the single AD condition regardless of diagnosis of PD and SAD. OCD scores did not differ among the 3 conditions while the scores in patients with OCD were significantly greater than those in patients without OCD. GAD scores in the multiple ADs plus MDD condition were significantly greater than those in the single AD and the multiple AD conditions. Moreover, in patients with MDD, the GAD scores in patients with GAD were not greater than those in patients without GAD. The results suggest that symptoms of PD, SAD, and GAD but not OCD are affected by the diagnosis of multiple ADs or comorbid MDD and that diagnosis of comorbid MDD affects GAD symptoms more strongly than diagnosis of GAD.
患有焦虑障碍 (AD) 的患者更有可能同时患有其他 AD 或重度抑郁症 (MDD)。然而,目前尚不清楚此类患者的焦虑症状是否比单一 AD 患者更严重。我们比较了单一 AD、多种 AD 和多种 AD 合并 MDD 患者的焦虑严重程度。研究对象为 136 名连续就诊的任何 AD 患者,对其进行了全面诊断。使用自评问卷测量惊恐障碍 (PD)、社交焦虑障碍 (SAD)、强迫症 (OCD) 和广泛性焦虑障碍 (GAD) 的症状严重程度,并比较了 3 种共病情况(单一 AD 与多种 AD 与多种 AD 合并 MDD)之间的评分。无论是否诊断为 PD 和 SAD,多种 AD 和多种 AD 合并 MDD 情况下的 PD 和 SAD 评分均明显高于单一 AD 情况下的评分。OCD 评分在 3 种情况下无差异,而 OCD 患者的评分明显高于无 OCD 患者的评分。多种 AD 合并 MDD 情况下的 GAD 评分明显高于单一 AD 和多种 AD 情况下的评分。此外,在患有 MDD 的患者中,患有 GAD 的患者的 GAD 评分并不高于没有 GAD 的患者。结果表明,PD、SAD 和 GAD 的症状而不是 OCD 的症状受多种 AD 诊断或合并 MDD 的影响,而合并 MDD 的诊断对 GAD 症状的影响强于 GAD 的诊断。