Mollahaliloglu Salih, Aydogan Ü, Kosdak M, Öncül H G, Dilmen U
Ministry of Health of Turkey, School of Public Health, Ankara, Turkiye.
Rural Remote Health. 2012;12:2067. Epub 2012 Nov 9.
A sufficient and balanced distribution of physicians plays a key role in access to high quality healthcare services. However, this issue presents serious problems globally. Turkey is currently experiencing physician shortages, with insufficient numbers of physicians in its rural and underdeveloped areas. The objectives of this study were to identify the views of new graduate physicians, prior to employment, on working in underdeveloped areas, in order to discover factors impacting their desire to work in these areas, and to show the actual geographic distribution of physicians in Turkey. This provides the basis for discussing future policies.
This study was conducted in Turkey from September to November 2009. All physicians (N=4753) who graduated in 2009 were included in the study via online questionnaires. The response rate was 78%. Variables potentially related to physicians' decisions to work in underdeveloped areas were analyzed using the χ(2) test. To discover the imbalance in geographic distribution of physicians, data collected by the Turkish Ministry of Health (MoH) were re-analyzed. Physician density was calculated for the six zones determined by the MoH according to socioeconomic development.
Of the physicians who participated, 52.5% were male and 13.5% expressed a desire to work in underdeveloped areas. Male physicians were more likely to work in underdeveloped areas (17.5% and 9.1%, respectively; p<0.05). There was a significant relationship between desire to work in underdeveloped areas, regions of longest stay and birthplace (p<0.05). Physicians who had lived for a significant period in areas with a high number of underdeveloped cities (Southeastern and Eastern Turkey) and those who were born in underdeveloped cities were more likely to wish to work in these areas. The most influential factor for working in these areas was higher salaries.
Physicians who have particular socioeconomic backgrounds such as rural origin and lower background-family income are more likely to have be motivated to work in underdeveloped areas. They are also more likely to accept work in these areas if financial and non-financial opportunities are provided. The findings of this study provide guidance for those revising health workforce policies.
医生的充分且均衡分布对于获得高质量医疗服务起着关键作用。然而,这个问题在全球范围内都存在严重挑战。土耳其目前正面临医生短缺的问题,其农村和欠发达地区的医生数量不足。本研究的目的是确定新毕业医生在就业前对在欠发达地区工作的看法,以发现影响他们在这些地区工作意愿的因素,并展示土耳其医生的实际地理分布情况。这为讨论未来政策提供了依据。
本研究于2009年9月至11月在土耳其进行。通过在线问卷,将2009年毕业的所有医生(N = 4753)纳入研究。回复率为78%。使用χ(2)检验分析可能与医生在欠发达地区工作决策相关的变量。为了发现医生地理分布的不均衡情况,对土耳其卫生部收集的数据进行了重新分析。根据社会经济发展情况,计算了卫生部确定的六个区域的医生密度。
参与研究的医生中,52.5%为男性,13.5%表示愿意在欠发达地区工作。男性医生在欠发达地区工作的可能性更大(分别为17.5%和9.1%;p<0.05)。在欠发达地区工作的意愿、最长居住地区和出生地之间存在显著关系(p<0.05)。在欠发达城市数量较多的地区(土耳其东南部和东部)居住过较长时间的医生以及出生在欠发达城市的医生更有可能希望在这些地区工作。在这些地区工作的最具影响力因素是更高的薪资。
具有特定社会经济背景(如农村出身和较低家庭背景收入)的医生更有可能有动力在欠发达地区工作。如果提供财务和非财务机会,他们也更有可能接受在这些地区的工作。本研究结果为修订卫生人力政策的人员提供了指导。