Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience, Biopsychology, Department of Psychology, Ruhr-University of Bochum, Bochum, Germany.
Laterality. 2013;18(5):536-75. doi: 10.1080/1357650X.2012.723008. Epub 2012 Nov 20.
There is considerable debate about whether population-level asymmetries in limb preferences are uniquely human or are a common feature among vertebrates. In the present article the results of studies investigating limb preferences in all non-extinct vertebrate orders are systematically analysed by employing cladographic comparisons. These studies analysed 119 different species, with 61 (51.26%) showing evidence for population-level asymmetries, 20 (16.81%) showing evidence for individual-level asymmetries and 38 (31.93%) showing no evidence for asymmetry. The cladographic comparison revealed that research in several key taxa in particular (e.g., Chondrichtyes, Crocodylia, Atlantogenata and Palaeognathae) would have important implications for our understanding of the evolution of vertebrate limb preferences. Furthermore, the findings of the present study support the position that population-level asymmetries in limb preferences as such represent a common vertebrate feature. Looking into the details, however, some important differences from human handedness become visible: Non-human limb preferences typically show a less-skewed lateralisation pattern and there are larger numbers of individuals without a preference in most species compared to humans. Moreover, limb preferences in non-human animals are often less task-invariant than human handedness and are more frequently modulated by external factors and individual characteristics.
关于肢体偏好的群体不对称性是否是人类独有的特征,还是脊椎动物的共同特征,存在很大的争议。在本文中,通过分支比较系统地分析了研究所有非灭绝脊椎动物目肢体偏好的结果。这些研究分析了 119 个不同的物种,其中 61 个(51.26%)显示出群体水平不对称的证据,20 个(16.81%)显示出个体水平不对称的证据,38 个(31.93%)没有显示出不对称的证据。分支比较显示,特别是在几个关键分类群(如软骨鱼纲、鳄形目、 Atlantogenata 和古颚总目)的研究将对我们理解脊椎动物肢体偏好的进化具有重要意义。此外,本研究的结果支持这样的观点,即肢体偏好的群体不对称性本身代表了一种常见的脊椎动物特征。然而,深入研究细节,可以发现一些与人类惯用手的重要区别:非人类的肢体偏好通常表现出较少偏侧化的模式,与人类相比,大多数物种中没有偏好的个体数量更多。此外,与人类惯用手相比,非人类动物的肢体偏好通常较少受任务影响,并且更容易受到外部因素和个体特征的调节。