The Department of Surgery, University of British Columbia, Vancouver General Hospital, Vancouver, BC.
Can J Surg. 2012 Dec;55(6):371-6. doi: 10.1503/cjs.011311.
Knowledge of the composition of a surgical team is the premise for studying efficiency inside the operating room.
To investigate the team composition in general surgery procedures, we retrospectively reviewed procedures performed by an expert general surgeon in 2007-08 at 2 tertiary hospitals. For each patient, demographic characteristics, procedure type, team members and procedure length were extracted from intraoperative nursing records. We assessed procedure complexity using a calculated index. Multiple logistic regressions were performed to assess the association between procedure length and team size after adjusting for procedure complexity and patient condition.
For the 587 procedures reviewed, the mean procedure length was 88 (standard deviation [SD] 51) minutes. On average, 8 team members (range 4-14), including surgeons, anesthesiologists, nurses and other specialists, were involved in each procedure. Only 47 (8%) procedures were performed by 1 surgeon. Most were performed by 2 (295 [50%]) or 3 surgeons (214 [36%]). Half the team members were nurses (mean 4, range 1-7). Both the complexity of the operation and the team size affected the procedure length significantly. When procedure complexity and patient condition were constant, adding 1 team member predicted a 7-minute increase in procedure length.
This study demonstrates that a frequent change of core team members has a negative impact on surgical performance. Management strategies need to improve to optimize team efficiency in the operating room.
了解手术团队的组成是研究手术室内部效率的前提。
为了研究普通外科手术中的团队构成,我们回顾性地分析了 2007-08 年一位专家普外科医生在 2 家 3 级医院进行的手术。对于每位患者,从术中护理记录中提取人口统计学特征、手术类型、团队成员和手术时间。我们使用计算指数评估手术复杂性。在调整手术复杂性和患者状况后,采用多变量逻辑回归分析手术时间与团队规模之间的关系。
共回顾了 587 例手术,平均手术时间为 88(标准差 51)分钟。平均有 8 名团队成员(范围 4-14 人),包括外科医生、麻醉师、护士和其他专家参与了每例手术。只有 47 例(8%)手术由 1 名外科医生完成。大多数手术由 2 名(295 例[50%])或 3 名外科医生(214 例[36%])完成。一半的团队成员是护士(平均 4 人,范围 1-7 人)。手术的复杂性和团队规模都显著影响手术时间。当手术的复杂性和患者的情况保持不变时,增加 1 名团队成员预计会使手术时间增加 7 分钟。
本研究表明,核心团队成员的频繁更换对手术绩效有负面影响。管理策略需要改进,以优化手术室的团队效率。