Peimer Clayton A, Blazar Philip, Coleman Stephen, Kaplan F Thomas D, Smith Ted, Tursi James P, Cohen Brian, Kaufman Gregory J, Lindau Tommy
College of Human Medicine, Michigan State University, Marquette General Healthcare, Marquette, MI 49855, USA.
J Hand Surg Am. 2013 Jan;38(1):12-22. doi: 10.1016/j.jhsa.2012.09.028. Epub 2012 Nov 30.
To evaluate long-term efficacy and safety of collagenase clostridium histolyticum (CCH) after the third year of a 5-year nontreatment follow-up study, Collagenase Option for Reduction of Dupuytren Long-Term Evaluation of Safety Study.
This study enrolled Dupuytren contracture patients from 5 previous clinical studies. Beginning 2 years after their first CCH injection, we re-evaluated patients annually for joint contracture and safety. Recurrence in a previously successfully treated joint (success = 0° to 5° contracture after CCH administration) was defined as 20° or greater worsening in contracture in the presence of a palpable cord or medical/surgical intervention to correct new or worsening contracture. We assessed partially corrected joints (joints reduced 20° or more from baseline contracture but not to 0° to 5°) for nondurable response, also defined as 20° or greater worsening of contracture or medical/surgical intervention.
Of 1,080 CCH-treated joints (648 metacarpophalangeal [MCP]; 432 proximal interphalangeal [PIP]; n = 643 patients), 623 (451 MCP, 172 PIP) had achieved 0° to 5° contracture in the original study. Of these joints, 35% (217 of 623) recurred (MCP 27%; PIP 56%). Of these recurrences, an intervention was performed in 7%. Of the 1,080 CCH-treated joints, 301 were partially corrected in the original study. Of these, 50% (150 of 301; MCP: 38% [57 of 152]; PIP: 62% [93 of 149]) had nondurable response. We identified no new long-term or serious adverse events attributed to CCH during follow-up. Anti-clostridial type I collagenase and/or anti-clostridial type II collagenase antibodies were reported for 96% or more of patients who received 2 or more CCH injections and 82% who received 1 injection.
The recurrence rate, which is comparable to other standard treatments, and the absence of long-term adverse events 3 years after initial treatment indicate that CCH is an effective and safe treatment for Dupuytren contracture. Most successfully treated joints had a contracture well below the threshold for surgical intervention 3 years after treatment. Recurrence rates among successfully treated joints were lower than nondurable response rates among partially corrected joints.
TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic IV.
在一项为期5年的非治疗随访研究(“用于减少掌腱膜挛缩的胶原酶长期安全性评估研究”)的第三年之后,评估溶组织梭状芽孢杆菌胶原酶(CCH)的长期疗效和安全性。
本研究纳入了来自之前5项临床研究的掌腱膜挛缩患者。在他们首次注射CCH两年后开始,我们每年对患者进行关节挛缩和安全性的重新评估。先前成功治疗的关节(成功定义为CCH给药后挛缩为0°至5°)复发定义为在存在可触及条索或进行医疗/手术干预以纠正新的或恶化的挛缩时,挛缩恶化20°或更多。我们评估了部分矫正的关节(关节挛缩较基线减少20°或更多但未达到0°至5°)的非持久反应,也定义为挛缩恶化20°或更多或进行医疗/手术干预。
在1080个接受CCH治疗的关节中(648个掌指关节[MCP];432个近端指间关节[PIP];n = 643例患者),623个(451个MCP,172个PIP)在原研究中达到了0°至5°挛缩。在这些关节中,35%(623个中的217个)复发(MCP为27%;PIP为56%)。在这些复发中,7%进行了干预。在1080个接受CCH治疗的关节中,301个在原研究中得到部分矫正。其中,50%(301个中的150个;MCP:38%[152个中的57个];PIP:62%[149个中的93个])有非持久反应。在随访期间,我们未发现归因于CCH的新的长期或严重不良事件。接受2次或更多次CCH注射的患者中96%以上以及接受1次注射的患者中82%报告了抗I型梭状芽孢杆菌胶原酶和/或抗II型梭状芽孢杆菌胶原酶抗体。
复发率与其他标准治疗相当,且初始治疗3年后无长期不良事件,表明CCH是治疗掌腱膜挛缩的有效且安全的方法。大多数成功治疗的关节在治疗3年后挛缩远低于手术干预阈值。成功治疗关节的复发率低于部分矫正关节的非持久反应率。
研究类型/证据水平:治疗性IV级。