Civello Andrea
Department of Philosophy, University of Pisa, via P. Paoli 15, 56126, Pisa, Italy,
J Hist Biol. 2013 Spring;46(1):125-58. doi: 10.1007/s10739-012-9346-4.
The idiotypic network theory (INT) was conceived by the Danish immunologist Niels Kaj Jerne in 1973/1974. It proposes an overall view of the immune system as a network of lymphocytes and antibodies. The paper tries to offer a reconstruction of the genesis of the theory, now generally discarded and of mostly historical interest, first of all, by taking into account the context in which Jerne's theoretical proposal was advanced. It is argued the theory challenged, in a sense, the supremacy of the clonal selection theory (CST), this being regarded as the predominant paradigm in the immunological scenario. As CST found shortcomings in explaining certain phenomena, anomalies, one could view INT as a competing paradigm claiming to be able to make sense of such phenomena in its own conceptual framework. After a summary outline of the historical background and some relevant terminological elucidations, a narrative of the various phases of elaboration of the theory is proposed, up to its official public presentation.
独特型网络理论(INT)由丹麦免疫学家尼尔斯·凯伊·耶尔恩在1973年/1974年提出。该理论将免疫系统视为淋巴细胞和抗体的网络,提出了一种整体观点。本文首先通过考虑耶尔恩提出理论建议的背景,试图对该理论的起源进行重构,该理论如今已普遍被摒弃,主要具有历史意义。有人认为,从某种意义上说,该理论挑战了克隆选择理论(CST)的主导地位,CST被视为免疫学领域的主要范式。由于CST在解释某些现象、异常情况时存在不足,因此可以将INT视为一种竞争范式,声称能够在其自身概念框架内解释此类现象。在对历史背景进行简要概述并对一些相关术语进行阐释之后,本文提出了该理论从阐述到正式公开呈现的各个阶段的叙述。