Department of Otolaryngology, Faculty of Medicine, Prince of Songkla University, Hat Yai, Songkhla, Thailand.
Am J Rhinol Allergy. 2012 Nov-Dec;26(6):455-62. doi: 10.2500/ajra.2012.26.3820.
Although combined oral and nasal steroid therapy is widely used in nasal polyposis, a subset of patients show an unfavorable therapeutic outcome. This study aimed to evaluate whether oral prednisolone produces any additive effects on subsequent nasal steroid therapy and to evaluate if any clinical variables can predict therapeutic outcome.
Using a 3:2 randomization ratio, 67 patients with nasal polyposis received 50 mg of prednisolone and 47 patients received placebo daily for 2 weeks, followed by mometasone furoate nasal spray (MFNS) at 200 micrograms twice daily for 10 weeks. Clinical response was evaluated by nasal symptom score (NSS), peak expiratory flow index (PEFI), and total nasal polyps score (TNPS). Potential predictor variables were assessed by clinical history, nasal endoscopy, allergy skin test, and sinus radiography.
At the end of the 2-week oral steroid phase, the prednisolone group showed significantly greater improvements in all nasal symptoms, nasal airflow, and polyp size than the placebo group. In the nasal steroid phase, while the MFNS maintained the outcome improvements in the prednisolone group, all outcome variables in the placebo group showed continuing improvements. At the end of the nasal steroid phase, there were no significant differences of most outcome improvements between the two groups, except in hyposmia, PEFI, and TNPS (p = 0.049, p = 0.029, and p = 0.005, respectively). In the prednisolone group, patients with polyps grade 3 and endoscopic signs of meatal discharge showed significantly less improvement in total NSS, PEFI, and TNPS than patients with grade 1-2 size and negative metal discharge.
In the 12-week treatment evaluation of nasal polyposis, pretreatment with oral steroids had no significant advantage for most nasal symptoms other than earlier relief; however, combined oral and nasal steroid therapy more effectively improved hyposmia, polyps size, and nasal airflow. Polyps size grade 3 and/or endoscopic signs of meatal discharge predisposed to a poorer treatment outcome.
尽管联合口服和鼻用类固醇治疗被广泛应用于鼻息肉,但有一部分患者的治疗效果并不理想。本研究旨在评估口服泼尼松龙是否对后续鼻用类固醇治疗有任何附加作用,并评估是否有任何临床变量可以预测治疗效果。
采用 3:2 随机分组比例,67 例鼻息肉患者每天接受 50mg 泼尼松龙治疗,47 例患者接受安慰剂治疗,持续 2 周,随后给予糠酸莫米松鼻喷雾剂(MFNS)200 微克,每日两次,持续 10 周。通过鼻症状评分(NSS)、呼气峰流速指数(PEFI)和总鼻息肉评分(TNPS)评估临床反应。通过临床病史、鼻内镜检查、过敏皮肤试验和鼻窦 X 线评估潜在的预测变量。
在 2 周的口服类固醇阶段结束时,与安慰剂组相比,泼尼松龙组在所有鼻部症状、鼻气流和息肉大小方面均有显著改善。在鼻用类固醇阶段,尽管 MFNS 维持了泼尼松龙组的治疗效果,但安慰剂组的所有结局变量仍在继续改善。在鼻用类固醇阶段结束时,两组之间除嗅觉减退、PEFI 和 TNPS 外(p=0.049、p=0.029 和 p=0.005),大多数结局改善均无显著差异(p=0.049、p=0.029 和 p=0.005)。在泼尼松龙组中,息肉 3 级和内镜下有脓性分泌物的患者的总 NSS、PEFI 和 TNPS 改善明显低于息肉 1-2 级且无脓性分泌物的患者。
在鼻息肉 12 周的治疗评估中,口服类固醇治疗除了早期缓解外,对大多数鼻部症状没有明显优势;然而,联合口服和鼻用类固醇治疗更有效地改善了嗅觉减退、息肉大小和鼻气流。息肉大小 3 级和/或内镜下有脓性分泌物提示治疗效果较差。