Zoppi G, Trucchi C
Department of Prevention, Local Health Agency 4 "Chiavarese", Liguria, Italy.
J Prev Med Hyg. 2012 Jun;53(2):125-9.
Vaccines able to prevent invasive bacterial diseases have been introduced into national and/or regional immunization plans through different strategies. We evaluated Haemophilus influenzae type b, Pneumococcus and Meningococcus C vaccination coverage in the 5 Ligurian Local Health Agencies, in the Liguria Region, and in Italy in order to assess the efficacy of current immunisation policies concerning children at the 24th month and adolescents. Furthermore, we considered new strategies for increasing vaccination coverage.
We estimated the vaccination coverage of Local Health Agency 4 by means of the "OASIS" software. The regional mean vaccination coverage was calculated from the data provided by the other four Local Health Agencies in Liguria. National data were obtained from the database of the Ministry of Health and from the last report of the ICONA Working Group. We used a questionnaire to evaluate the knowledge of Meningococcus C vaccination among the pediatricians and general practitioners operating in our Local Health Agency.
The regional vaccination coverage at the 24th month proved to be: > 95% for Haemophilus influenzae type b, 93% for Pneumococcus and 87% for Meningococcus C. The national mean is: > 95% for Haemophilus influenza type b, 55% for Pneumococcus and 37% for Meningococcus C. Meningococcus C vaccination coverage among adolescents is 49% in Liguria, while the national mean is 16%. The questionnaire administered to the physicians was composed of 5 questions, which were answered by 81% of pediatricians and only 22% of general practitioners. Reducing the incidence of invasive meningococcal diseases through large-scale vaccination was deemed very important by 92% of pediatricians and 81% of general practitioners. About 92% of pediatricians and 85% of general practitioners considered the vaccine safe and effective. All (100%) physicians expressed their agreement with the Ligurian immunization strategy. However, while all the pediatricians reported recommending this vaccination, only 76% of general practitioners did so. Finally, all the physicians interviewed stated their willingness to collaborate with the Department of Prevention to increase vaccination coverage.
VC against Hib at the 24th month, in both Liguria and Italy, proved excellent. Compliance with vaccination against Pneumococcus has been very high since its introduction in 2003 in Liguria, while the national mean is suboptimal. The regional vaccination coverage against Meningococcus C at the 24th month is good; the national value, however, is low because some Italian Regions have not yet introduced this vaccination into their immunization plans. Vaccination coverage in adolescents varies widely among the Ligurian Local Health Agencies and needs to be increased; the national figure is very low because few Regions have introduced this vaccination. However, achieving compliance with vaccinations in adolescents is difficult. The questionnaire indicated that general practitioners place less emphasis on vaccinations than pediatricians. Nevertheless, both general practitioners and pediatricians expressed their willingness to collaborate with the Department of Prevention of Local Health Agency 4 in improving the immunization strategies aimed at adolescents.
In conclusion, we consider it very important to create a network involving the Department of Prevention, pediatricians and general practitioners, in order to share the best immunization strategies.
能够预防侵袭性细菌疾病的疫苗已通过不同策略被纳入国家和/或地区免疫规划。我们评估了利古里亚地区5个地方卫生机构、利古里亚大区以及意大利的b型流感嗜血杆菌、肺炎球菌和C群脑膜炎球菌疫苗接种覆盖率,以评估当前针对24个月大儿童和青少年的免疫政策的效果。此外,我们还考虑了提高疫苗接种覆盖率的新策略。
我们通过“绿洲”软件估算了第4地方卫生机构的疫苗接种覆盖率。大区平均疫苗接种覆盖率根据利古里亚其他四个地方卫生机构提供的数据计算得出。国家数据来自卫生部数据库和ICONA工作组的最新报告。我们使用一份问卷来评估在我们地方卫生机构工作的儿科医生和全科医生对C群脑膜炎球菌疫苗接种的了解情况。
24个月时的大区疫苗接种覆盖率显示为:b型流感嗜血杆菌>95%,肺炎球菌93%,C群脑膜炎球菌87%。全国平均值为:b型流感嗜血杆菌>95%,肺炎球菌55%,C群脑膜炎球菌37%。利古里亚青少年的C群脑膜炎球菌疫苗接种覆盖率为49%,而全国平均值为16%。向医生发放的问卷由5个问题组成,81%的儿科医生和仅22%的全科医生回答了问卷。92%的儿科医生和81%的全科医生认为通过大规模接种疫苗降低侵袭性脑膜炎球菌疾病的发病率非常重要。约92%的儿科医生和85%的全科医生认为该疫苗安全有效。所有(100%)医生都表示同意利古里亚的免疫策略。然而,虽然所有儿科医生都报告推荐这种疫苗接种,但只有76%的全科医生这样做。最后,所有接受采访的医生都表示愿意与预防部门合作以提高疫苗接种覆盖率。
在利古里亚和意大利,24个月时针对b型流感嗜血杆菌的疫苗接种覆盖率都非常出色。自2003年在利古里亚引入肺炎球菌疫苗接种以来,其依从性一直很高,而全国平均值并不理想。24个月时针对C群脑膜炎球菌的大区疫苗接种覆盖率良好;然而,全国数值较低,因为一些意大利大区尚未将这种疫苗接种纳入其免疫规划。利古里亚各地方卫生机构中青少年的疫苗接种覆盖率差异很大,需要提高;全国数据非常低,因为很少有大区引入这种疫苗接种。然而,实现青少年疫苗接种的依从性很困难。问卷表明,全科医生对疫苗接种的重视程度低于儿科医生。尽管如此,全科医生和儿科医生都表示愿意与第4地方卫生机构的预防部门合作,以改进针对青少年的免疫策略。
总之,我们认为建立一个由预防部门、儿科医生和全科医生组成的网络以分享最佳免疫策略非常重要。