Division of Sports Medicine, Department of Family Medicine, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43221, USA.
Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2013 Jun;45(6):1105-12. doi: 10.1249/MSS.0b013e31827fdf18.
This study compared the effect of immediate versus delayed massage-like compressive loading (MLL) on peak isometric torque recovery and inflammatory cell infiltration after eccentric exercise (EEX).
Eighteen skeletally mature New Zealand White rabbits were instrumented with peroneal nerve cuffs for the stimulation of hindlimb tibialis anterior muscles. After a bout of EEX, rabbits were randomly assigned to an MLL protocol (0.5 Hz, 10 N, 15 min) that started immediately post-EEX, 48 h post-EXX, or no-MLL control and performed for four consecutive days. A torque-angle (T-Θ) relationship was obtained for 21 joint angles pre- and post-EEX and after four consecutive days of MLL or no-MLL. Muscle wet weights and immunohistochemical sections were obtained after final treatments.
EEX produced an average 51% ± 13% decrease in peak isometric torque output. The greatest peak torque recovery occurred with the immediate application of MLL. There were differences in torque recovery between immediate and delayed MLL (P = 0.0012), immediate MLL and control (P < 0.0001), and delayed MLL and control (P = 0.025). Immunohistochemical analysis showed 39.3% and 366.0% differences in the number of RPN3/57 and CD11b-positive cells between immediate (P = 0.71) and delayed MLL (P = 0.12). The area under the T-Θ curve showed a difference for immediate (P < 0.0001) and delayed (P = 0.0051) MLL as compared with control. Exercise produced an average 10° ± 0.2° rightward shift from preexercise peak isometric torque angle. Control, immediate MLL, and delayed MLL produced an average leftward angular shift from the postexercise angle (P = 0.28, P = 0.03, and P = 0.47, respectively).
Post-EEX, immediate MLL was more beneficial than delayed MLL in restoring muscle function and in modulating inflammatory cell infiltration. These findings invite similar human studies to make definitive conclusions on optimal timing of massage-based therapies.
本研究比较了即刻与延迟按摩样压缩负荷(MLL)对离心运动(EEX)后峰值等长扭矩恢复和炎症细胞浸润的影响。
18 只骨骼成熟的新西兰白兔被安置在腓肠神经袖带中,用于刺激后肢胫骨前肌。EEX 后,兔子被随机分配到 MLL 方案(0.5 Hz,10 N,15 min)中,该方案在 EEX 后即刻、48 小时后或无 MLL 对照组开始,并连续进行四天。在 EEX 前后和连续四天 MLL 或无 MLL 处理后,获得 21 个关节角度的扭矩-角度(T-Θ)关系。在最后一次处理后获得肌肉湿重和免疫组织化学切片。
EEX 导致峰值等长扭矩输出平均下降 51%±13%。即刻应用 MLL 可获得最大的峰值扭矩恢复。即刻和延迟 MLL 之间(P=0.0012)、即刻 MLL 和对照组之间(P<0.0001)以及延迟 MLL 和对照组之间(P=0.025)的扭矩恢复存在差异。免疫组织化学分析显示,即刻(P=0.71)和延迟(P=0.12)MLL 之间的 RPN3/57 和 CD11b 阳性细胞数量分别有 39.3%和 366.0%的差异。T-Θ 曲线下面积在即刻(P<0.0001)和延迟(P=0.0051)MLL 与对照组之间存在差异。运动导致从预运动峰值等长扭矩角度向右平均偏移 10°±0.2°。对照组、即刻 MLL 和延迟 MLL 分别从运动后角度向左产生平均角度偏移(P=0.28、P=0.03 和 P=0.47)。
EEX 后,即刻 MLL 在恢复肌肉功能和调节炎症细胞浸润方面比延迟 MLL 更有益。这些发现邀请类似的人类研究来对基于按摩的治疗的最佳时机做出明确的结论。