Yitzhak Moran, Sarnat Haim, Rakocz Meir, Yaish Yaniv, Ashkenazi Malka
The Maurice and Gabriela Goldschleger School of Dental Medicine, Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv, Israel.
Spec Care Dentist. 2013 Jan-Feb;33(1):20-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1754-4505.2012.00311.x. Epub 2012 Nov 20.
To compare the effectiveness of two toothbrush designs in tooth brushing by nurses of individuals with cerebral palsy.
Following instruction, nurses brushed the teeth of 21 individuals with a single-headed-toothbrush, and 22 with a triple-headed-toothbrush. After one month, the nurses brushed their patients with the other toothbrush, following instruction. Tooth brushing performance skill was evaluated and scored using the TB-PS-I/Ashkenazi index following the first brushing as well as on a recall visit one month later.
After 1 month, 7.6% of the nurses required further instruction following brushing with the triple-headed toothbrush compared to 15% after brushing with the single-headed. Reductions in plaque and gingival indices were greater after using the triple- headed than single-headed toothbrush. More nurses preferred the triple-headed toothbrush (75.5% compared to 22.6%).
Brushing by nurses of cerebral palsy patients was more effective and instruction better retained with a triple-headed compared to single-headed toothbrush.
比较两种牙刷设计对脑瘫患者进行刷牙护理时的效果。
在指导下,护士用单头牙刷为21名患者刷牙,用三头牙刷为22名患者刷牙。一个月后,护士按照指导用另一种牙刷为患者刷牙。在首次刷牙后以及一个月后的回访中,使用TB-PS-I/阿什克纳齐指数对刷牙操作技能进行评估和评分。
1个月后,使用三头牙刷刷牙后,7.6%的护士需要进一步指导,而使用单头牙刷刷牙后这一比例为15%。使用三头牙刷后牙菌斑和牙龈指数的降低幅度大于单头牙刷。更多护士更喜欢三头牙刷(75.5%,而单头牙刷为22.6%)。
与单头牙刷相比,使用三头牙刷对脑瘫患者进行刷牙护理更有效,且护士能更好地记住操作指导。