Faculty of Medicine, Memorial University of Newfoundland, St John's, Newfoundland, Canada.
Med Educ. 2013 Jan;47(1):33-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2923.2012.04262.x.
At the 100th anniversary of Abraham Flexner's landmark report on medical education, critical reassessment of the direction of medical education reform evinced valuable interdisciplinary contributions from biomedicine, sociology, psychology and education theory. However, to date, philosophy has been absent from the discussion despite its long standing contribution to studies on education in other professions.
This discussion paper examines how the philosophical tradition can contribute to scholarship in medical education. It begins with an explanation of the scholarly tradition of philosophy of education and its role in thinking in education more generally. It then makes links between this tradition and the context of medical education in the Flexner era of education reform. The paper then argues that this tradition is necessary to the understanding of medical education reform post-Flexner and that doctors must benefit from an education derived from this tradition in order to be able to carry out their work.
These foundations are characterised as a hidden, but always present, tradition in medical education. Two ways in which this 'lost tradition' can inform medical education theory and practice are identified: firstly, by the establishment of a public canon of medical education texts that express such a tradition, and, secondly, by the incorporation of a variety of 'signature pedagogies' exemplary of liberal education.
在 Abraham Flexner 关于医学教育的里程碑式报告发表 100 周年之际,对医学教育改革方向的批判性重新评估显示,生物医学、社会学、心理学和教育理论等多学科做出了宝贵的贡献。然而,迄今为止,尽管哲学在其他专业的教育研究中做出了长期贡献,但它一直缺席讨论。
本文探讨了哲学传统如何为医学教育研究做出贡献。它首先解释了教育哲学的学术传统及其在更广泛的教育思考中的作用。然后,它在 Flexner 时代的医学教育改革背景下建立了这种传统与医学教育之间的联系。本文接着认为,这种传统对于理解 Flexner 之后的医学教育改革是必要的,医生必须受益于这种传统的教育,才能开展他们的工作。
这些基础被描述为医学教育中的一个隐藏但始终存在的传统。确定了这种“失落的传统”可以为医学教育理论和实践提供两种信息途径:一是建立一个表达这种传统的医学教育文本公共正典,二是纳入各种体现自由教育的“标志性教学法”。