Ashwal S, Schneider S, Tomasi L, Thompson J
Department of Pediatrics, Loma Linda University School of Medicine, CA 92350.
Neurology. 1990 May;40(5):820-3. doi: 10.1212/wnl.40.5.820.
We retrospectively examined the clinical courses of 20 children with severe near-drowning and divided their outcomes into 3 groups: normal (4), persistent vegetative state (9), and dead (7). We reviewed serial blood glucose levels and cerebral blood flow measured by stable xenon computed tomography within the 1st 48 hours of admission to determine whether they were predictive of outcome. Total, frontal gray, frontal white, and temporal and parietal gray matter cerebral blood flows were significantly decreased in children who died compared with those who completely recovered. Only 1/2 the children surviving in a vegetative state had decreased flows compared with those who recovered. An elevated initial blood glucose was highly predictive of those patients who died (mean, 511 +/- 110 mg%) or those with vegetative survival (465 +/- 104 mg%) compared with those who recovered completely (238 +/- 170 mg%). The predictive value of initial blood glucose alone (68%) or CBF alone (50%) was similar to that of clinical rating scales or immersion/resuscitation times. The combination of blood glucose with CBF improved predictability to 79%. Our results suggest that CBF measurements are predictive of eventual death but cannot differentiate normal from vegetative survival. Combining multiple laboratory studies may be of value in predetermining the eventual outcome in near-drowning.
我们回顾性研究了20例重度溺水儿童的临床病程,并将其结局分为3组:正常(4例)、持续性植物状态(9例)和死亡(7例)。我们回顾了入院后最初48小时内通过稳定氙计算机断层扫描测量的系列血糖水平和脑血流量,以确定它们是否能预测结局。与完全康复的儿童相比,死亡儿童的总脑血流量、额叶灰质、额叶白质以及颞叶和顶叶灰质的脑血流量均显著降低。与康复儿童相比,处于植物状态存活的儿童中只有一半脑血流量降低。与完全康复的儿童(238±170mg%)相比,初始血糖升高高度预示着死亡患者(平均511±110mg%)或植物状态存活患者(465±104mg%)。单独初始血糖(68%)或单独脑血流量(50%)的预测价值与临床评分量表或溺水/复苏时间的预测价值相似。血糖与脑血流量相结合可将预测性提高至79%。我们的结果表明,脑血流量测量可预测最终死亡,但无法区分正常结局与植物状态存活结局。综合多项实验室研究可能有助于预先确定溺水后的最终结局。