Department of Political Science, University of North Texas, 1155 Union Circle #305340, Denton, TX 76203-5340, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2013 Apr;82:126-33. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2012.12.021. Epub 2012 Dec 28.
Previous research shows no consensus as to whether and how natural disasters affect suicide rates in their aftermath. Using prefecture-level panel data of natural disasters and suicide in Japan between 1982 and 2010, we estimate both contemporaneous and lagged effects of natural disasters on the suicide rates of various demographic groups. We find that when the damage caused by natural disasters is extremely large, as in the case of the Great Hanshin-Awaji Earthquake in 1995, suicide rates tend to increase in the immediate aftermath of the disaster and several years later. However, when the damage by natural disasters is less severe, suicide rates tend to decrease after the disasters, especially one or two years later. Thus, natural disasters affect the suicide rates of affected populations in a complicated way, depending on the severity of damages as well as on how many years have passed since the disaster. We also find that the effects of natural disasters on suicide rates vary considerably across demographic groups, which suggests that some population subgroups are more vulnerable to the impact of natural disasters than others. We then test the possibility that natural disasters enhance people's willingness to help others in society, an effect that may work as a protective factor against disaster victims' suicidal risks. We find that natural disasters increase the level of social ties in affected communities, which may mitigate some of the adverse consequence of natural disasters, resulting in a decline in suicide rates. Our findings also indicate that when natural disasters are highly destructive and disruptive, such protective features of social connectedness are unlikely to be enough to compensate for the severe negative impact of disasters on health outcomes.
先前的研究对于自然灾害是否以及如何影响灾后的自杀率尚未达成共识。本文利用日本 1982 年至 2010 年间的自然灾害和自杀事件的县级面板数据,对自然灾害对各人口群体自杀率的同期和滞后效应进行了估计。我们发现,当自然灾害造成的破坏非常大时,如 1995 年阪神大地震,自杀率在灾害发生后的短期内和几年后都有上升的趋势。然而,当自然灾害的破坏程度较小时,自杀率往往在灾害发生后下降,尤其是一两年后。因此,自然灾害对受灾人群的自杀率的影响是复杂的,取决于灾害破坏的严重程度以及灾害发生后经过的年数。我们还发现,自然灾害对自杀率的影响在不同的人口群体中差异很大,这表明一些人口群体比其他群体更容易受到自然灾害的影响。我们随后检验了自然灾害是否会增强人们在社会中帮助他人的意愿,这种意愿可能成为灾害受害者自杀风险的一种保护因素。我们发现,自然灾害增加了受灾社区的社会联系水平,这可能减轻了自然灾害的一些不利后果,从而降低了自杀率。我们的研究结果还表明,当自然灾害具有很强的破坏性和颠覆性时,社会联系的这种保护作用可能不足以弥补灾害对健康结果的严重负面影响。