Henny C J, Burke P M
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Patuxent Wildlife Research Center, Laurel, Maryland 20708.
Arch Environ Contam Toxicol. 1990 Jan-Feb;19(1):132-7. doi: 10.1007/BF01059821.
Fluoride was measured in femurs of black-crowned night-herons (Nycticorax nycticorax) living adjacent to a phosphate processing complex near Pocatello, Idaho. Fluoride (ash wt.) in femurs ranged from 540 micrograms/g to 11,000 micrograms/g and increased (P = 0.0001) with age, but with no difference (P = 0.80) between sexes. Adult males (greater than or equal to 4 years) contained 5,409 micrograms/g compared to 6,042 micrograms/g for adult females. The tibiotarsus (= tibiae in text) increased in diameter with age (P = 0.015) in this study; fluoride was nearly related (P = 0.065) to the increase. As the diameter increased with age, wall thickness decreased (P = 0.011) suggesting excessive internal bone resorption, but fluoride concentrations were not implicated in the relationship (p = 0.64). The apparent increase in diameter and decrease in wall thickness may have partially neutralized each other's effects on strength. Although significantly higher concentrations of fluoride were present in adults than in Third Year herons, no significant change in bone strength (maximum load or modulus of rupture) was detected between the two age classes, but three of the four comparisons showed adults with less strength (i.e., a hint of diminished strength with age). The tibiae of Hatch Year birds were significantly weaker than documented in older age classes, but incomplete growth was thought responsible. The strong relationship between age and fluoride concentrations reduced our ability to separate a "fluoride effect" from an "age effect." Other authors believed fluoride was responsible for an increase in bone diameter and the fluoride residues encountered in adults were within the range indicative of poisoning in cattle.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
对生活在爱达荷州波卡特洛附近一个磷酸盐加工厂区附近的黑冠夜鹭(夜鹭属)股骨中的氟化物进行了测量。股骨中的氟化物(灰分重量)含量在540微克/克至11,000微克/克之间,并随年龄增长而增加(P = 0.0001),但两性之间无差异(P = 0.80)。成年雄性(大于或等于4岁)的含量为5,409微克/克,成年雌性为6,042微克/克。在本研究中,胫跗骨(文中等同于胫骨)直径随年龄增加(P = 0.015);氟化物与这种增加几乎相关(P = 0.065)。随着直径随年龄增加,壁厚减小(P = 0.011),表明存在过度的内部骨吸收,但氟化物浓度与这种关系无关(P = 0.64)。直径的明显增加和壁厚的减小可能部分抵消了彼此对强度的影响。尽管成年夜鹭体内的氟化物浓度明显高于三岁夜鹭,但在这两个年龄组之间未检测到骨强度(最大负荷或断裂模量)有显著变化,但四项比较中有三项显示成年夜鹭的强度较低(即有随年龄强度降低的迹象)。幼鸟的胫骨明显比年长组记录的要弱,但认为是生长不完全所致。年龄与氟化物浓度之间的强关系降低了我们将“氟化物效应”与“年龄效应”区分开的能力。其他作者认为氟化物是导致骨直径增加的原因,并且在成年夜鹭中发现的氟化物残留量在表明牛中毒的范围内。(摘要截断于250字)