Division of Infectious Diseases, Washington University School of Medicine, 660 S. Euclid, St. Louis, MO 63110, USA.
Int J Antimicrob Agents. 2013 Mar;41(3):272-7. doi: 10.1016/j.ijantimicag.2012.10.023. Epub 2013 Jan 9.
There is a dearth of guidance on the management of prosthetic joint infections (PJIs), in particular because of the lack of high-quality evidence for optimal antibiotics. Thus, we designed a nine-question survey of current practices and preferences among members of the Emerging Infections Network, a CDC-sponsored network of infectious diseases physicians, which was distributed in May 2012. In total, 556 (47.2%) of 1178 network members responded. As first-line antibiotic choice for MSSA PJI, 59% of responders indicated oxacillin/nafcillin, 33% cefazolin and 7% ceftriaxone; the commonest alternative was cefazolin (46%). For MRSA PJI, 90% preferred vancomycin, 7% daptomycin and 0.8% ceftaroline; the commonest alternative was daptomycin (65%). Antibiotic selection for coagulase-negative staphylococci varied depending on methicillin susceptibility. For staphylococcal PJIs with retained hardware, most providers would add rifampicin. Propionibacterium is usually treated with vancomycin (40%), penicillin (23%) or ceftriaxone (17%). Most responders thought 10-19% of all PJIs were culture-negative. Culture-negative PJIs of the lower extremities are usually treated with a vancomycin/fluoroquinolone combination, and culture-negative shoulder PJIs with vancomycin/ceftriaxone. The most cited criteria for selecting antibiotics were ease of administration and the safety profile. A treatment duration of 6-8 weeks is preferred (by 77% of responders) and is mostly guided by clinical response and inflammatory markers. Ninety-nine percent of responders recommend oral antibiotic suppression (for varying durations) in patients with retained hardware. In conclusion, there is considerable variation in treatment of PJIs both with identified pathogens and those with negative cultures. Future studies should aim to identify optimum treatment strategies.
目前针对人工关节感染(PJI)的管理缺乏指导,特别是由于缺乏高质量的证据来确定最佳抗生素。因此,我们设计了一项针对新兴感染网络(CDC 赞助的传染病医生网络)成员当前实践和偏好的九项问题调查,该调查于 2012 年 5 月进行。在总共 1178 名网络成员中,有 556 名(47.2%)做出了回应。对于 MSSA PJI 的一线抗生素选择,59%的应答者表示选择苯唑西林/萘夫西林,33%选择头孢唑林,7%选择头孢曲松;最常见的替代药物是头孢唑林(46%)。对于 MRSA PJI,90%的人首选万古霉素,7%的人首选达托霉素,0.8%的人首选头孢地尔;最常见的替代药物是达托霉素(65%)。凝固酶阴性葡萄球菌的抗生素选择取决于耐甲氧西林情况。对于保留内植物的葡萄球菌 PJI,大多数提供者会添加利福平。痤疮丙酸杆菌通常用万古霉素(40%)、青霉素(23%)或头孢曲松(17%)治疗。大多数应答者认为所有 PJI 中有 10-19%的为培养阴性。下肢培养阴性 PJI 通常用万古霉素/氟喹诺酮类药物联合治疗,肩部培养阴性 PJI 则用万古霉素/头孢曲松治疗。选择抗生素的最主要依据是给药的便利性和安全性。6-8 周的治疗疗程是首选(77%的应答者),主要根据临床反应和炎症标志物来决定。99%的应答者建议在保留内植物的患者中使用口服抗生素抑制(持续不同时间)。总之,对于有明确病原体和培养阴性的 PJI,治疗方法存在很大差异。未来的研究应该旨在确定最佳的治疗策略。