Gratwohl A, Hermans J, Barrett A J, Ernst P, Frassoni F, Gahrton G, Granena A, Kolb H J, Prentice H G, Vernant J P
Department of Internal Medicine, University Hospital Basel, Switzerland.
Bone Marrow Transplant. 1990 Mar;5(3):159-65.
The results of 1904 allogeneic HLA identical sibling donor bone marrow transplants performed in 52 European centers between 1979 and 1986 and reported to the EBMT leukemia registry were analysed by geographical location of the transplant. Patients were grouped into six regions: United Kingdom, Nordic Group, Benelux, France, Central Europe and Southern Europe. There were significant differences between these regions with respect to patient population and outcome. The relative proportion of the three major disease categories, stage and subtype of the diseases, graft-versus-host disease prevention methods, donor recipient sex combinations, age of the patient, year of the transplant and the time intervals from diagnosis to transplant, from diagnosis to first complete remission for acute leukemia and the time from first complete remission to the transplant varied from region to region. The analysis of outcome parameters showed a significant difference in relapse incidence from region to region. This influence of region was confirmed in a multivariate analysis and was independent of the other factors known to affect outcome. Leukemia-free survival and transplant-related mortality were not different. The reasons for these differences could not be explained by the data in the registry. We conclude that regional factors must be considered when bone marrow transplant data are compared and we postulate that pretransplant factors probably affect outcome more than was previously realized.
对1979年至1986年间在52个欧洲中心进行的1904例同种异体 HLA 相同同胞供者骨髓移植结果进行分析,这些结果已上报至欧洲骨髓移植白血病登记处,分析依据移植的地理位置展开。患者被分为六个区域:英国、北欧组、比荷卢经济联盟、法国、中欧和南欧。这些区域在患者群体和预后方面存在显著差异。三大主要疾病类别、疾病分期和亚型、移植物抗宿主病预防方法、供受者性别组合、患者年龄、移植年份以及从诊断到移植的时间间隔、急性白血病从诊断到首次完全缓解的时间以及从首次完全缓解到移植的时间在不同区域各不相同。对预后参数的分析显示,不同区域的复发率存在显著差异。在多变量分析中证实了区域的这种影响,且该影响独立于其他已知影响预后的因素。无白血病生存率和移植相关死亡率并无差异。登记处的数据无法解释这些差异的原因。我们得出结论,在比较骨髓移植数据时必须考虑区域因素,并且我们推测移植前因素对预后的影响可能比之前认识到的更大。