Schoevaerts K, Bruffaerts R, Mulder C L, Vandenberghe J
UPC-KU Leuven, Leuven.
Tijdschr Psychiatr. 2013;55(1):45-55.
Although compulsory admission (CA) is highly relevant to society, epidemiological data for European countries are scarce and of limited reliability and comparability. In several European countries the incidence of CA seems to be increasing.
To estimate the incidence and evolution of CA in Belgium and the Netherlands by pooling and analysing available epidemiological data.
We reviewed the literature systematically, paying particular attention to relevant epidemiological data (in published articles and in grey literature). All data were (re)calculated into yearly incidence rates of CA per 100,000 inhabitants.
The incidence of CA increased by 42% in Belgium (1999-2008) and by 25% in the Netherlands (2002-2009), culminating in incidence rates of 47/100,000/y (Belgium, 2008) and 80/100.000/y (Netherlands, 2009). Between-country differences can be attributed partly to differences in the legal systems. More detailed results, regional differences, and problems with the comparison of epidemiological data on CA are discussed.
Our data point to a significant increase of the incidence of CA in both Belgium and the Netherlands. To improve the comparability and quality of the data on CA, European countries will need to strive for greater uniformity and standardisation in the way these data are registered.
尽管强制入院(CA)与社会高度相关,但欧洲国家的流行病学数据稀缺,可靠性和可比性有限。在几个欧洲国家,强制入院的发生率似乎在上升。
通过汇总和分析现有流行病学数据,估计比利时和荷兰强制入院的发生率及其变化情况。
我们系统地回顾了文献,特别关注相关流行病学数据(发表文章和灰色文献中的数据)。所有数据都被(重新)计算为每10万居民的年度强制入院发生率。
比利时的强制入院发生率在1999 - 2008年间上升了42%,荷兰在2002 - 2009年间上升了25%,最终发生率分别为47/10万/年(比利时,2008年)和80/10万/年(荷兰,2009年)。国家间的差异部分可归因于法律制度的差异。文中还讨论了更详细的结果、地区差异以及强制入院流行病学数据比较方面的问题。
我们的数据表明比利时和荷兰的强制入院发生率均显著上升。为提高强制入院数据的可比性和质量,欧洲国家需要在这些数据的登记方式上努力实现更大程度的统一和标准化。