Department of Respiratory Medicine, Flinders Medical Centre, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia.
Intern Med J. 2013 Jan;43(1):96-100. doi: 10.1111/imj.12019.
Pleural effusion is a common medical condition encountered by doctors. This study was conducted to ascertain the level of junior doctor (physician-in-training) training, knowledge and supervision in the management of pleural effusion. The information was collected with the help of a proforma, from 49 junior medical doctors working in a metropolitan health service. All the doctors who participated in the survey had come across pleural effusion in their practice, but only 67% of doctors had any experience with the procedure of diagnostic thoracentesis. Sixty-seven percent of doctors conveyed that they will refer the majority of cases (75-100%) for radiological-guided thoracentesis. The main reasons for referral for radiologically guided procedure were lack of experience (65%), fear of complications (61%), lack of supervision and guidance (49%), and lack of time (38%). A significant proportion of doctors interviewed (47%) was unaware of the major indications for intercostal tube drainage of parapneumonic effusions. This survey highlights deficiencies in junior doctor knowledge and procedural skills. Junior doctor training should be tailored to increase the 'hands-on' training time and increased patient contact. Senior clinicians should be given sufficient 'protected time' for teaching and training.
胸腔积液是医生经常遇到的一种常见病症。本研究旨在确定初级医生(住院医师)在胸腔积液管理方面的培训、知识和监督水平。这项信息是通过一份调查问卷,从在一个大都市卫生服务机构工作的 49 名初级医生那里收集到的。所有参与调查的医生在实践中都遇到过胸腔积液,但只有 67%的医生有过诊断性胸腔穿刺术的经验。67%的医生表示,他们将把大多数病例(75-100%)转诊给放射引导下的胸腔穿刺术。转诊进行放射引导程序的主要原因是缺乏经验(65%)、担心并发症(61%)、缺乏监督和指导(49%)以及缺乏时间(38%)。接受采访的医生中有相当一部分(47%)不知道治疗脓胸性胸腔积液的肋间引流的主要适应证。这项调查突出了初级医生知识和程序技能方面的不足。初级医生的培训应该根据增加“实践”培训时间和增加患者接触来进行调整。应该为资深临床医生提供足够的“保护时间”进行教学和培训。