Schoenfeld Andrew J, Carey Paul A, Frye Brandon D, Weaver Courtney R, Belmont Philip J
William Beaumont Army Medical Center, El Paso, TX 79920, USA.
J Surg Orthop Adv. 2012 Winter;21(4):204-9. doi: 10.3113/jsoa.2012.0204.
Many research abstracts presented at orthopaedic conferences do not undergo a formal editorial, or peer-review process; however, abstracts are frequently referenced in textbooks and influence clinical practice. The purpose of this study was to determine the publication rate of abstracts formally presented at the Society of Military Orthopaedic Surgeons (SOMOS) annual meetings from 1998 to 2006 that went to full-text publication. Using Google Scholar and PubMed, a literature search was performed for each abstract presented at the annual SOMOS meeting in the years 1998-2006, to calculate the overall full-text publication rate, the average duration from presentation to publication, and the distribution of publications in the various journals. A total of 770 abstracts were presented at the annual SOMOS meetings. The overall full-text publication rate at a minimum of 3 years was 45.7% (352 publications). The average time from presentation to publication was 2.7 years. The published articles appeared in 65 peer-reviewed journals, with notable distribution in Spine (10.0%), The American Journal of Sports Medicine (9.4%), and The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery (9.4%). The full-text publication rate of abstracts presented at the annual SOMOS meetings compares favorably with that of other major orthopaedic conferences in the United States. Nonetheless, more than half of abstracts presented at the SOMOS meetings remain unpublished.
在骨科会议上展示的许多研究摘要并未经过正式的编辑或同行评审过程;然而,这些摘要经常在教科书中被引用并影响临床实践。本研究的目的是确定1998年至2006年在军事骨科外科医生协会(SOMOS)年会上正式展示并全文发表的摘要的发表率。使用谷歌学术和PubMed,对1998 - 2006年SOMOS年会展示的每篇摘要进行文献检索,以计算总体全文发表率、从展示到发表的平均时长以及在各种期刊上的发表分布情况。SOMOS年会上共展示了770篇摘要。至少3年的总体全文发表率为45.7%(352篇发表)。从展示到发表的平均时间为2.7年。发表的文章出现在65种同行评审期刊上,在《脊柱》(10.0%)、《美国运动医学杂志》(9.4%)和《骨与关节外科杂志》(9.4%)上分布显著。SOMOS年会展示的摘要的全文发表率与美国其他主要骨科会议相比具有优势。尽管如此,SOMOS会议上展示的摘要仍有一半以上未发表。