Department of Experimental Clinical and Health Psychology, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium Centre for Pain Research, The University of Bath, Claverton Down, Bath BA2 7AY, UK.
Pain. 2013 Apr;154(4):497-510. doi: 10.1016/j.pain.2012.11.013. Epub 2012 Dec 5.
This meta-analysis investigated whether attentional bias, that is, the preferential allocation of attention to information that is related to pain, is a ubiquitous phenomenon. We also investigated whether attentional bias effects are related to the methodological quality of the study, to procedural differences in their measurement, or to individual differences in pain severity, pain-related fear, anxiety, and depression. Results indicated that individuals who experience chronic pain (n=1023) display an attentional bias towards pain-related words or pictures, but this bias was of a small effect size (d=0.134), and did not differ from that in control groups (d=0.082; n=1398). No evidence was found for an attentional bias towards pain-related words and pictures for acute pain (d=0.049), procedural pain (d=0.142), and experimental pain (d=0.069). However, research in which attentional bias towards signals of impending experimental pain in healthy volunteers was investigated, revealed an attentional bias of medium effect size (d=0.676). Moderator analyses in the chronic pain group identified important procedural variables that affected the presence and magnitude of an attentional bias towards pain-related words and pictures, that is, type and exposure time of pain-related information. None of the individual difference variables affected the magnitude of the attentional bias. Implications of current findings and future directions are discussed.
这项荟萃分析旨在探讨注意偏向(即,偏向于与疼痛相关的信息分配注意力)是否是一种普遍现象。我们还调查了注意偏向效应是否与研究的方法学质量、其测量的程序差异或个体在疼痛严重程度、与疼痛相关的恐惧、焦虑和抑郁方面的差异有关。结果表明,患有慢性疼痛的个体(n=1023)对与疼痛相关的单词或图片表现出注意偏向,但这种偏向的效应量较小(d=0.134),且与对照组无差异(d=0.082;n=1398)。对于急性疼痛(d=0.049)、程序性疼痛(d=0.142)和实验性疼痛(d=0.069),没有证据表明存在对与疼痛相关的单词和图片的注意偏向。然而,对于健康志愿者中对即将到来的实验性疼痛信号的注意偏向的研究,发现了一个中等效应量的注意偏向(d=0.676)。慢性疼痛组的调节分析确定了重要的程序变量,这些变量影响了对与疼痛相关的单词和图片的注意偏向的存在和程度,即与疼痛相关信息的类型和暴露时间。个体差异变量均未影响注意偏向的程度。目前研究结果的意义和未来方向进行了讨论。