Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Clinical Scholars Program, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, CT, USA.
Cancer J. 2013 Jan-Feb;19(1):1-9. doi: 10.1097/PPO.0b013e3182821930.
Following the acute phase of treatment, national guidelines recommend cancer survivors have routine contact with health care providers and undergo basic ancillary testing while avoiding high-cost imaging (HCI). We conducted this study to determine how frequently breast, prostate, and colorectal cancer survivors received recommended follow-up care and HCI tests during the survivorship period.
Using administrative data from TRICARE beneficiaries, we identified a cohort of patients who were treated for breast, prostate, or colorectal cancer between October 2005 and March 2007. These patients were then followed through September 2010. During the 3 years after initial treatment, we determined how frequently survivors received all minimum recommended survivorship care as defined by national guidelines and underwent HCI tests and if these outcomes varied by geographic region.
Overall, 3148 patients underwent treatment for breast (n = 1630), prostate (n = 1173), or colorectal (n = 345) cancer. Sixty-five percent received all minimum recommended care over 3 years (breast = 74.1%, prostate = 65.3%, colorectal = 25.5%). During the 3-year period, 74.1% of breast cancer survivors received a mammogram each year, whereas 69.1% of colorectal cancer survivors had at least 1 colonoscopy. Sixty-four percent had at least 1 HCI study during the 3-year period (positron emission tomography = 10.9%, computer tomography = 48.8%, magnetic resonance imaging = 36.6%) at a cost of $3.5 million. Substantial state-level variation was noted for both outcomes.
Some cancer survivors do not receive recommended care following initial treatment while frequently undergoing HCI. The existing geographic variation in quality and imaging utilization suggests that improvements to cancer survivorship care are possible.
在治疗的急性期过后,国家指南建议癌症幸存者与医疗保健提供者保持常规联系,并进行基本的辅助检查,同时避免使用高成本的影像学检查(HCI)。我们进行这项研究是为了确定在生存期间,乳腺癌、前列腺癌和结直肠癌幸存者接受推荐的随访护理和 HCI 检查的频率。
我们使用来自 TRICARE 受益人的行政数据,确定了一组在 2005 年 10 月至 2007 年 3 月期间接受乳腺癌、前列腺癌或结直肠癌治疗的患者。然后,这些患者一直随访到 2010 年 9 月。在初始治疗后的 3 年内,我们确定了幸存者接受国家指南定义的所有最低限度推荐生存护理的频率,以及进行 HCI 检查的频率,以及这些结果是否因地理位置而异。
总体而言,3148 名患者接受了乳腺癌(n=1630)、前列腺癌(n=1173)或结直肠癌(n=345)的治疗。65%的患者在 3 年内接受了所有最低限度的推荐护理(乳腺癌=74.1%,前列腺癌=65.3%,结直肠癌=25.5%)。在 3 年期间,74.1%的乳腺癌幸存者每年接受一次乳房 X 光检查,而 69.1%的结直肠癌幸存者至少进行了 1 次结肠镜检查。64%的患者在 3 年内至少进行了 1 次 HCI 研究(正电子发射断层扫描=10.9%,计算机断层扫描=48.8%,磁共振成像=36.6%),费用为 350 万美元。这两个结果都存在显著的州级差异。
一些癌症幸存者在初始治疗后没有接受推荐的护理,同时经常进行 HCI。现有的质量和影像学利用方面的地理差异表明,癌症生存护理的改善是可能的。