Riggs E R, Wain K E, Riethmaier D, Smith-Packard B, Faucett W A, Hoppman N, Thorland E C, Patel V C, Miller D T
Department of Human Genetics, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, GA, USA.
Clin Genet. 2014 Feb;85(2):147-53. doi: 10.1111/cge.12107. Epub 2013 Feb 21.
Chromosomal microarray analysis (CMA) is standard of care, first-tier clinical testing for detection of genomic copy number variation among patients with developmental disabilities. Although diagnostic yield is higher than traditional cytogenetic testing, management impact has not been well studied. We surveyed genetic services providers regarding CMA ordering practices and perceptions about reimbursement. Lack of insurance coverage because of perceived lack of clinical utility was cited among the most frequent reasons why CMA was not ordered when warranted. We compiled a list of genomic regions where haploinsufficiency or triplosensitivity cause genetic conditions with documented management recommendations, estimating that at least 146 conditions potentially diagnosable by CMA testing have published literature supporting specific clinical management implications. Comparison with an existing clinical CMA database to determine the proportion of cases involving these regions showed that CMA diagnoses associated with such recommendations are found in approximately 7% of all cases (n = 28,526). We conclude that CMA impacts clinical management at a rate similar to other genetic tests for which insurance coverage is more readily approved. The information presented here can be used to address barriers that continue to contribute to inequities in patient access and care in regard to CMA testing.
染色体微阵列分析(CMA)是发育障碍患者基因组拷贝数变异检测的标准治疗方法和一线临床检测手段。尽管其诊断率高于传统细胞遗传学检测,但对管理的影响尚未得到充分研究。我们就CMA的订购实践以及对报销的看法对遗传服务提供者进行了调查。在有必要进行CMA检测但未进行检测的最常见原因中,提到了因认为缺乏临床实用性而导致保险覆盖不足。我们编制了一份基因组区域清单,其中单倍剂量不足或三剂量敏感性会导致遗传疾病并有记录在案的管理建议,估计至少有146种可能通过CMA检测诊断的疾病有已发表的文献支持特定的临床管理意义。与现有的临床CMA数据库进行比较以确定涉及这些区域的病例比例,结果显示与此类建议相关的CMA诊断在所有病例(n = 28,526)中约占7%。我们得出结论,CMA对临床管理的影响率与保险覆盖更容易获批的其他基因检测相似。此处提供的信息可用于消除那些继续导致患者在CMA检测的获取和护理方面存在不公平现象的障碍。