Wayne State University, Department of Emergency Medicine, Detroit, Michigan.
West J Emerg Med. 2012 Nov;13(5):394-400. doi: 10.5811/westjem.2011.12.6815.
The incidence of emergency department (ED) visits for Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) in the United States exceeds 1,000,000 cases/year with the vast majority classified as mild (mTBI). Using existing computed tomography (CT) decision rules for selecting patients to be referred for CT, such as the New Orleans Criteria (NOC), approximately 70% of those scanned are found to have a negative CT. This study investigates the use of quantified brain electrical activity to assess its possible role in the initial screening of ED mTBI patients as compared to NOC.
We studied 119 patients who reported to the ED with mTBI and received a CT. Using a hand-held electroencephalogram (EEG) acquisition device, we collected data from frontal leads to determine the likelihood of a positive CT. The brain electrical activity was processed off-line to generate an index (TBI-Index, biomarker). This index was previously derived using an independent population, and the value found to be sensitive for significant brain dysfunction in TBI patients. We compared this performance of the TBI-Index to the NOC for accuracy in prediction of positive CT findings.
Both the brain electrical activity TBI-Index and the NOC had sensitivities, at 94.7% and 92.1% respectively. The specificity of the TBI-Index was more than twice that of NOC, 49.4% and 23.5% respectively. The positive predictive value, negative predictive value and the positive likelihood ratio were better with the TBI-Index. When either the TBI-Index or the NOC are positive (combining both indices) the sensitivity to detect a positive CT increases to 97%.
The hand-held EEG device with a limited frontal montage is applicable to the ED environment and its performance was superior to that obtained using the New Orleans criteria. This study suggests a possible role for an index of brain function based on EEG to aid in the acute assessment of mTBI patients.
美国每年因创伤性脑损伤(TBI)而前往急诊部(ED)就诊的人数超过 100 万,其中绝大多数为轻度(mTBI)。使用现有的计算机断层扫描(CT)决策规则来选择需要进行 CT 检查的患者,如新奥尔良标准(NOC),大约 70%的扫描患者的 CT 结果为阴性。本研究旨在探讨量化脑电活动在 ED mTBI 患者的初步筛查中的可能作用,并与 NOC 进行比较。
我们研究了 119 例因 mTBI 而到 ED 就诊并接受 CT 检查的患者。使用手持式脑电图(EEG)采集设备,我们从额导联采集数据,以确定 CT 阳性的可能性。离线处理脑电活动以生成指数(TBI 指数,生物标志物)。该指数是使用独立人群得出的,发现该指数对 TBI 患者的大脑功能障碍具有敏感性。我们将 TBI 指数与 NOC 的预测阳性 CT 结果的准确性进行了比较。
脑电活动 TBI 指数和 NOC 的敏感性分别为 94.7%和 92.1%。TBI 指数的特异性明显高于 NOC,分别为 49.4%和 23.5%。阳性预测值、阴性预测值和阳性似然比均随着 TBI 指数的升高而升高。当 TBI 指数或 NOC 阳性时(两者结合),检测阳性 CT 的敏感性提高至 97%。
具有有限额导联的手持式 EEG 设备适用于 ED 环境,其性能优于使用新奥尔良标准获得的性能。本研究表明,基于 EEG 的脑功能指数在辅助急性 mTBI 患者评估方面可能具有一定作用。