Zhong Xiaohong, Nagase Takashi, Huang Lijuan, Kaitani Toshiko, Iizaka Shinji, Yamamoto Yuko, Kanazawa Toshiki, Sanada Hiromi
Department of Nursing, Nanfang Hospital, Southern Medical University, Guangzhou, Guangdong, China.
Ostomy Wound Manage. 2013 Feb;59(2):36-43.
Lack of a valid and reliable assessment instrument may have contributed to a lack of wound healing research in China. The DESIGN-R tool scores the severity of pressure ulcers (PUs) and monitors healing using the observable state assessment; it was developed by the Scientific Education Committee of the Japanese Society of Pressure Ulcers (JSPU) and tested for reliability and validity. A Chinese version of DESIGN-R was developed based on Brislin's model of translationand tested for validity and reliability. Using a purposive sampling method, 44 practicing registered nurses (RNs) and 11 physicians (MDs) were recruited from 52 departments of Nanfang Hospital, Guangdong, China. Based on their experience, they were classified as general medical staff (gMS) or experienced medical staff (eMS). All used the Chinese version of DESIGN-R to assess eight photographs of PUs and descriptors. In addition, eight eMS also used the Bates- Jensen Wound Assessment Tool (BWAT) to assess the same wounds. Inter-rater reliability was high (total ICC score = 0.960). ICC inflammation/infection scores were 0.530 and 0.759 for gMS and eMS, respectively; granulation ICC scores were 0.532 and 0.794 in gMS and eMS, respectively. The correlation coefficients between the BWAT and DESIGN-R tool were >0.80 for all eight raters. The results suggest the Chinese version of DESIGN-R is valid and reliable and may be a useful scoring tool for RNs and MDs to monitor PU status in daily clinical practice. Additional research is warranted, and clinical instruments for inflammation/infection and granulation assessment must be developed for gMS.
缺乏有效且可靠的评估工具可能导致了中国伤口愈合研究的匮乏。DESIGN-R工具用于对压疮(PU)的严重程度进行评分,并通过可观察状态评估来监测愈合情况;它由日本压疮学会(JSPU)科学教育委员会开发,并经过了信效度测试。基于Brislin的翻译模型开发了DESIGN-R的中文版,并进行了信效度测试。采用目的抽样法,从中国广东南方医院的52个科室招募了44名执业注册护士(RN)和11名医生(MD)。根据他们的经验,将他们分为普通医务人员(gMS)或经验丰富的医务人员(eMS)。所有人都使用DESIGN-R中文版对8张压疮照片和描述符进行评估。此外,8名eMS还使用贝茨-詹森伤口评估工具(BWAT)对相同的伤口进行评估。评分者间信度较高(总ICC分数=0.960)。gMS和eMS的ICC炎症/感染分数分别为0.530和0.759;gMS和eMS的肉芽组织ICC分数分别为0.532和0.794。所有8名评分者的BWAT与DESIGN-R工具之间的相关系数均>0.80。结果表明,DESIGN-R中文版有效且可靠,可能是注册护士和医生在日常临床实践中监测压疮状态的有用评分工具。有必要进行更多研究,并且必须为普通医务人员开发用于炎症/感染和肉芽组织评估的临床工具。